RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

The Marlboro Man: He’s A Real Human Being

[I changed the previous post to one about the cost of the Iraq war -- $1.5 trillion and counting -- and how the pre-war promises of the Bush administration about cheap oil and lower costs at our gas pumps have not only not come true, but continue to mean that we may be stuck in Iraq for a hell of a long time. NOW the rest of that previous post.]

2002086301.jpg

From Keith Olbermann’s Countdown, November 12, 2007:

[F]ew who saw this image of Lance Corporal James Blake Miller in November 2004 is likely to have forgotten it or to forget it. In the years since this photograph of the then 20-year-old dubbed the Marlboro marine was taken, Corporal Miller has been kicked out of the military for, quote, “Personality disorder” when he had trouble adjusting life back at Camp Lejeune, he‘s been divorced, he‘s been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, jobless and at times suicidal, helped most not by the government but principally by the “L.A. Times” photographer who took that picture. As promised, let‘s turn now to Paul Rieckhoff, executive director and founder of Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America. …

From a 2006 Knight-Ridder story published in The Seattle Times:

Former Marine is “Marlboro Man” no more
By Jim Warren
Knight Ridder Newspapers

2002754382.jpg

CAPTION: Now clean-cut with brown hair and a thin mustache, Blake Miller doesn’t look much like that 2004 photograph.

LONG FORK, Ky. — The steep mountainsides in western Pike County are painted in the drabbest of winter browns and grays now, but already there is a feeling in the air that the land is ready to break out with spring color.

Maybe that’s a good omen for a young man back home after a tour in Iraq but still struggling to cope with the psychological shocks that cut short his career in the U.S. Marine Corps.

Millions of Americans remember him only as the “Marlboro Man”: the grubby, exhausted Marine lance corporal with a cigarette dangling from his lips in a famous 2004 photograph from the battle for Fallujah. The picture became one of the iconic images of the Iraq war.

Around Pike County, though, he’s just plain Blake Miller, 21, and a civilian again. Today, he’s intent on getting over the blackouts and the nightmares, and building a new life with his new wife, Jessica.

And the man whose image became a symbol of the war now wrestles with his own feelings about the conflict.

Today, he doesn’t look much like that 2004 photograph. … READ ALL.

UPDATE: “Despite concerns of overstepping, Times photographer Luis Sinco feels compelled to help the Iraq vet he made famous.” The Los Angeles Times is running several articles on that famous photograph that Luis Sinco snapped, and on Sinco’s efforts to help that “wounded warrior.”

Here’s the beginning of one of those remarkable articles — and the link takes you to the rest of the articles and a photo gallery:

Rescue operation aims to save a wounded warrior

By Luis Sinco : Times Staff Photographer, Second of two parts
November 12, 2007

James Blake Miller was in a world of pain, and I figured I should be by his side.

A veterans’ treatment program in West Haven, Conn. — arguably the best in the nation — offered hope. Moe Armstrong, a pioneer in vet-to-vet counseling, had heard of the Marlboro Marine’s troubles and sent him feelers about coming for a visit. Despite my reservations about getting too involved, I had flown from Los Angeles to Kentucky to help Miller grab this lifeline. I coaxed him into my rental car and we headed north.

I questioned myself. Was this the right thing to do? For Miller, yes. But for me? What awaited us at the end of this journey? I caught Miller’s eyes reflected in the rearview mirror, droopy and lifeless. He hadn’t slept well, and a long road led from his home in the Appalachian coal country to New England.

I had taken a photo of Miller for the Los Angeles Times during the battle of Fallouja in November 2004. He was leaning against a wall, a cigarette dangling from his lips. To my surprise, the image became iconic, capturing a sense of the front line in a young Marine’s face. It appeared in dozens of newspapers and on TV broadcasts, giving Miller a moment of fame.

Back home, he had struggled to put Iraq behind him. He was medically discharged from the Marines, suffering from post- traumatic stress disorder. He suffered flashbacks, drank heavily and retreated into a shell.

We had stayed in touch, casually at first. Then something deeper had developed between us. I was one of the few people who could reach him, who understood what he had been through.

I’d flown east in June 2006 after Miller’s wife called me, asking for help. …

READ ALL.

UNRELATED / ALSO at ThinkFast today:

“The income gap between black and white families has grown,” according to a new study by the Brookings Institution. One reason for the widening gap is that “incomes among black men have actually declined in the past three decades, when adjusted for inflation.”

  • ybnormal

    Related but not directly on topic; I’m reminded of a thought for yesterday, Veteran’s Day.

    Besides the physical sacrifice that soldiers make, there’s another. All soldiers can, potentially at least, face a crisis of conscience. It’s way easier for those who never face battle to have morally right opinions about fighting. It’s much less easy for someone standing in battle in uniform with a weapon in hand.

    Soldiers sacrifice a certain measure of self-determination for actions according to conscience. When faced with such a crisis, the choice then is, either rationalize the action, or a lifetime as a renegade.

    In such a crisis, is there really a right answer?

    • Taters

      Well said yb.

    • Shirin

      In my opinion yes, there IS a right answer. The answer is just say no to killing and maiming and destroying the lives of other human beings, particularly when those human beings have never done anything to harm or threaten the United States.

      Just say no to participation in war crimes such as the disgustingly deceptively named “Battle For Falluja”. At least call it what it is – the annihilation of a city.

  • http://papertigertail.blogspot.com Other Lisa

    I read that story yesterday. It’s heartbreaking. This young man has a long road ahead of him.

  • Mary

    Anyone who reads it and sees what his brother says could pretty easily understand the military recruiting problems now and in the future.

    The story hits at least a little on every large and looming issue that needs to be addressed, but in the end it is a very personal story. At times, it almost seemed to invasive to read it and I very much hope for the best for Mr. Miller (damn, so many have been so young) and his family.

    When the story discusses his reaction, in 06, feeling that even if things began to change right then it was already too late – it’s like peeling off scabs to read.

    • http://cujo359.blogspot.com Cujo359

      The people who run this country seem to give no thought to the future. They let things like this happen to these young people who have been to war, knowing full well that anyone smart enough to see or hear about stories like this one would probably choose not to be in the military. It’s the same sort of thinking that lets them allow the people who worked for us as translators to remain in limbo, rather than doing its utmost to make sure the can find asylum here or elsewhere outside Iraq. [SusanUnPC wrote about that a week or so ago].

      Not only have we squandered our image as a humane people by kidnapping and torturing people from all over the world with little if any actual result, but now we’ve shown ourselves to be uninterested in helping the people who’ve given up so much to work for us.

      • Shirin

        The people who run this country have nearly always been far too ready to use military force and massive violence as a political and economic tool. This current administration might be the worst – or at least among the worst – so far in history, but they did not invent this type of criminal behaviour.

        Old men and women send the young to die and be mentally and physically maimed for their ambitions and lust for power, but that’s not the worst of it. Entire countries are destroyed, millions of human beings are killed, become destitute refugees, and are mentally and physically maimed by the young who are sent to do the dirty work of the old. An entire generation of Iraqis will now grow up and live for the rest of their lives with the mental and physical devastation brought on them by those young Americans doing the bidding of egotistical, greed-driven old men.

        And you can’t divide Iraqis into innocent and non-innocent. Those Iraqis who resist the youn g Americans who are destroying their country are no less worthy of life than are non-combatants. Most of those resistance fighters were ordinary, productive human beings with families before they had this situation forced on them. Attacking foreign invading and occupying forces is far, far more honourable and heroic than being part of the attacking and invading forces.

        What if they gave a war and no one showed up? What if one day every one of the young people sent to Iraq to kill and destroy human life for the enrichment of the egos and pockets of old men did what Agustín Aguayo did throughout his service there, and refused to carry a loaded weapon?

        And what if everyone understood his moral responsibility as Camilo Mejia does:

        I say without any pride that I did my job as a soldier. I commanded an infantry squad in combat and we never failed to accomplish our mission. But those who called me a coward, without knowing it, are also right. I was a coward not for leaving the war, but for having been a part of it in the first place. Refusing and resisting this war was my moral duty, a moral duty that called me to take a principled action. I failed to fulfill my moral duty as a human being and instead I chose to fulfill my duty as a soldier. All because I was afraid. I was terrified, I did not want to stand up to the government and the army, I was afraid of punishment and humiliation. I went to war because at the moment I was a coward, and for that I apologize to my soldiers for not being the type of leader I should have been.

  • http://thumbsnap.com/v/78mn2yFc.jpg 1Watt

    I hope this report is true:

    http://www.buzzflash.net/story.php?id=31057

    • Kathleen

      what do they need to impeach this psychopath?

      Oh I know can someone please step up to the plate and give this man a bj

  • Pingback: The Marlboro Man: He’s A Real Human Being « Rochester Liberal

  • justsomeone

    Cujo359, if you want to help the Iraqi interpreters call your Senators & if you want to help vets there are alot of organizations desperately trying to do just that. “Coalition to Salute Americas Heroes”, “Wounded Warrior Project”, just look on the net they’re lots of veterans groups out there having to beg for $$. The V.A. will eventually get around to helping, even if it’s 20 yrs from now (like the agent orange victims from Nam) in the meantime I damn do what I can. Take a look at the friggin “Base Realignment Program” the military is selling bases to private developers to convert to high-end condos & boutique shopping centers, etc & the military won’t even try to negoiate a few lousey units of housing for our most severely wounded vets & their families. Why don’t you call those morons in D.C. & raise hell about that? And believe me the damn dems are as guilty, if not more so than the republicans, on helping the developers scarf off with some fine real estate & screw Iraq/Afghanistan vets. H.U.D. has a little provision wherein they have to “give shelter” to a few homeless vets. So if a vet spends 20-30 yrs on the streets, gets a drug jones, stays drunk, & in general becomes a pain in the ass to society THEN there’s going to be a little help…I’m so ticked, so pissed. Check out the V.A.’s web site: lots of states don’t even have any applications in for housing grants

  • TeakwoodKite

    Oh to be Humbled by the honest errors of others.
    On CountDown last night Keith O corrected an error in reporting he had made. Bottomline is there are 194,000 homeless vets. That is more than all the armed forces currently serving in Iraq….support that.

    • http://noquarterusa.net/ SusanUnPC

      Wow. 194,000. That’s about 194,000 too many.

  • Kathleen

    Hundreds of thousand of deaths and injuries all a result of an invasion based on a “pack of lies”

    http://www.robert-fisk.com/iraqwarvictims_page20.htm

  • Aeon

    We are all “collateral damage” – except for the 1% SICK PSYCOPATHS pulling the strings.

    Time to cut the strings.


    “How does it become a man to behave toward this American government to-day?
    I answer that he cannot without disgrace be associated with it.”

    – Henry David Thoreau

    • Montag

      I believe Thoreau said that about our first War For Empire, the 1846-48 War with Mexico, which gained us the Southwest.

  • Bill Keyes

    The answer to all the above is Impeachment..

    Call you Congressperson and ask them if they support the cheney impeachment resolution HR 799 and if they don’t ask them to give you an answer in writing.

    • Kathleen

      Thanks for the reminder. We need to keep calling.

      All we are saying is give impeachment a chance.

  • Thinker

    Susan I have no sympathy for those that chose to go to war. Anything short of death must be welcome and nothing less than death should be expected.

    • Shirin

      Thinker, I share your view. Those who take part in the invasion and occupation, and devastation of Iraq have choices at every point along the way, and if they choose to be part of a violent action in a foreign land, then they should accept the consequences of their choices.

      • caitlan and bryan elkins

        Are you in the military?
        Have you ever been in a war?
        To have some like you dis on them for keeping our country safe, which seems to me like your not in the military then you have no room to state what you did!

  • justsomeone

    F OFF with your Hate The Troops dribble

  • dudor

    twat

    old bean

  • Bryan and Caitlan Elkins

    What you have stated above on the picture of the marlboro man is COMPLETELY untrue!!! Saying, Corporal Miller has been kicked out of the military for, quote, “Personality disorder” when he had trouble adjusting life back at Camp Lejeune, he‘s been divorced, he‘s been diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, jobless and at times suicidal, Where exactly do you get this information about him? For one, he was honorably discharged NOT “kicked out”! Honestly do you really know this man like my husband does? James Blake Miller is his cousin, coming back from killing men will of course be a life changing situation for him so don’t put “trouble adjusting” to life, till you go over there and fight like a real man or women! Also you have no right to put that he has been divorced into any of this, that is his own personal life that has no need for the public eye! Also the economy is horrible and for a small town like Pike County Kentucky it’s hard to find a job so again why you thought it was ok to but “jobless” is beyond me. Making him sound like some low life helpless man because of post- traumatic stress disorder. And unless you know him like we do, how dare you put that he is at times “suicidal”. You have no clue who he is or what is he like. So till you can get your information right maybe you should look into another income of a job because this is the most pathetic thing i think some low life can put up here about a hero!!!

    • http://sarainitalyblog.blogspot.com/ American Girl in Italy

      I saw your comments, but not sure anyone else will. This post is from 2007, and the comments you are referring to were quotes from Keith Olbermann.

      Susan put this piece together quoting other articles, and Olbermann. If you have issue with the content you stated, you should take it up with Olbermann. (who I despise!)

      Personally, I think Susan was trying to point out how the war can destroy our good men – not make him sound like a lowlife.

      He is definitely a hero.

      • Bryan and Caitlan Elkins

        How do i get ahold of this person then, because i do NOT like how they put things together about him!
        It’s a disgrace to our family!!!

  • Бенедикт

    You don’t must be a military or be in a war for understanding this real facts

    http://http://www.worldcallapse.ru