RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

Turning Black Liquor into Gold–And You Pick Up The Bar Tab

webrblackliquor_edited-21

Why are these happy guys celebrating? According to a disturbing story by Christopher Hayes they may have just scored lots of our hard earned tax dollars by doing something outrageous.

Let’s start from the beginning so you can see how shameful this travesty is. Black Liquor provides much of the fuel used to make paper. The great thing about Black Liquor is that it is a byproduct then put to good use.

Hayes describes it as follows:

Since the 1930s the overwhelming majority of paper mills have employed what’s called the kraft process to produce paper…Wood chips are cooked in a chemical solution to separate the cellulose fibers, which are used to make paper, from the other organic material in wood. The remaining liquid, a sludge containing lignin (the structural glue that binds plant cells together), is called black liquor. Because it’s so rich in carbon, black liquor is a good fuel; the kraft process uses the black liquor to produce the heat and energy necessary to transform pulp into paper. It’s a neat, efficient process that’s cost-effective without any government subsidy.

So far so good. But here’s the harsh rub. The paper industry has figured out how to get taxpayers’ money—billions of it–by doing something wickedly creative. Oh, and they screw with the enviornment at the same time. A “twofer” disgrace.

Thanks to an obscure tax provision, the United States government stands to pay out as much as $8 billion this year to the ten largest paper companies. And get this: even though the money comes from a transportation bill whose manifest intent was to reduce dependence on fossil fuel, paper mills are adding diesel fuel to a process that requires none in order to qualify for the tax credit. In other words, we are paying the industry–handsomely–to use more fossil fuel. “Which is,” as a Goldman Sachs report archly noted, the “opposite of what lawmakers likely had in mind when the tax credit was established.”

So, adding the unnecessary diesel fuel to black liquor qualifies for a mixed-fuel tax credit, allowing them, as Hayes puts it, to turn black liquor into gold.

Many critics are saying that stimulus money will primarily go to those who need it the least. Stories like this make me sadly realize that they are probably right.

  • KintheNorthwest

    Ty for the story. Am I surprised NO!!!

  • http://www.rabblerouserruminations.blogspot.com/ Rabble Rouser Reverend Amy

    Holy smokes, Pat! Great toon – well done!

    And YES, this is infuriating!!! I am so sick of these companies getting away with taking OUR money!!!!

  • Don X

    Great toon and issue, Pat. The rich get richer and the poor get poorer. The corporate greedy always find a way to twist things to their advantage. Screw everyoe else.

  • NoTrollZone

    Great work Pat. Thanks for bringing attention to this issue. That’s also a really good piece you link to. My personal favorite line is:

    “You use the toilet every day,” said one hedge fund analyst who’s been closely following the issue. “Imagine if you could start pouring a little gasoline into the bowl and get fifty cents a gallon every time you flushed.”

    But never fear, Congress is looking into it….

  • http://ksclematis ksclematis

    Pat: Thanks for bringing this to the attention to those of us who were unaware it was being done!!…another great ‘toon. You certainly are doing a civic duty by presenting your topics in cartoon fashion. I believe people can identify the discrepancies and falaciousness better This is just one of many, many ways in which we are helping those who are NOT helping us, and the government is supporting this. It’s difficult to fathom the ways in which we are being bilked without any transparency….

    No matter what the politicians of any of the parties say out of both sides of their mouths, they expect us to believe every word. We are having a city election on Tuesday, and I was reading what each candidate was ‘promising’. In one category a candidate may say one thing and in another category he/she may say the opposite. How can we realistically choose any candidate that will meet our expectations after being elected???

  • Blue Orchid

    This story is outrageous beyond belief. We ought to change or abolish said tax provision at once.

  • http://ksclematis ksclematis

    OOoooops! Sorry about the misspelling…it’s “fallaciousness”. The Add Comment key was hit while I was editing the message….

  • http://noquarter foxyladi14

    yes we should..but we can’t..

  • mountainaires

    Great post, Pat, and as always, fantastic cartoon. Either our Congress is just not up to the task, or they purposefully designed legislation around this creatively wicked entreprenurial plot.

    Good one, Pat!

  • Tricia Spiegel

    LOL NoTrollZone, that was my favorite line also!

  • Pat Racimora

    Thanks for the nice comments so far. This story upset me so much that I had to have a drink!

  • Solara 7

    I feel like we are one of those third world countries where the aid money to people who desperately need it is upsurped by the bullies on top. The desperate stay desperate.

  • NoTrollZone

    Man, now that is an insightful comment. You are spot on.

  • clairtx

    Let’s add all the so called ‘farmers’ who keep a few head of cattle on their property or grow a hay crop and get subsidized for that. There are so many ways the rich rip off the rest of us in this country, and our elected officials let them get away with it, while our boys and girls sacrifice their lives in other countries to protect our freedom.

    America – love it or leave it.

  • Vicki D

    This website rules. Great post Pat.

    Congress needs to be voted out in 2010. The leadership is corrupt and obsolete.

  • WMCB

    It’s called a corrupt Banana Republic. And yes, we are becoming the largest Banana Republic in the world.

  • Docelder

    We now reward those who game the system and we punish those who try to do the right thing. There is also a “bio-diesel” tax credit of $1 per gallon. Oil companies mix tankers full of regular diesel with a small amount of bio-diesel and then “export” the tanker of diesel to Europe, taking diesel we need overseas and then they take the $1 a gallon tax credit for the entire tanker full of diesel even though only a small portion of bio-diesel was ever used. The “fat finger” of government. I don’t know whether to give up and try to convince the wife to expatriate or find some government scam to get into. I know one thing, doing the right thing is swimming against the current and wearing concrete shoes while doing it.

  • Solara 7

    Outrageous! This is even worse. No wonder us little people are flaling about.

  • Rich

    I love your cartoons, but why are you so upset?

    By now you should get used to the fact that greed is alive and well and everyone knows that the government is the easiest one to take advantage. One reason is that seldom anything serious happens to the offender and sometime they even get hired for a high power position and the second reason is that no one in the government suffers when it is wasted. It is not their money!!. Our high powered government officials, like the executives of large corporations who got us or their companies into trouble get their raises anyway, and to get someone in government to loose their job, if married they fist have to have sex with someone who is not their spouse, or if not married someone of the same sex.

    Do I hear more people interested in mandatory term limits?

    Rich

  • TeakwoodKite

    By now you should get used to the fact that greed is alive.

    Respectfully, no thanks.

  • TeakwoodKite

    Great pic, Pat. So who sponsored this little gem?

    I thank you for raising yet another example of pork by any means.

  • SoCalGal

    Wonderful cartoon! Pork seems to be everywhere. Voting day 2010 won’t come soon enough.

  • http://hot-news.dreamhosters.com/age-spots-on-a-banana Hot News » Age Spots On A Banana

    [...] shu uemura Spot Brightener : TalkingMakeup.com: Daily makeup and beauty blog and makeup tutorials…Turning Black Liquor into Gold–And You Pick Up The Bar Tab : NO QUARTER…the saga continues: the israel strikes back. « art is hard….Uncle Briggs « The [...]

  • Laura Sanborn

    Does anyone have a list of the paper companies.
    Really interested in the Maine Mills

blog comments powered by Disqus