Democracy Abolished by Howard Dean and Barack Obama [Updated]
By SusanUnPC on April 1, 2008 at 10:23 PM in Barack Obama, Democrats, Donna Brazile, Florida, Hillary Clinton, Howard Dean, Michigan
Written by Mel with minor additions from Uppity Woman and me. Video thanks to C.S.
It’s fair to say that we expect our leaders to educate us accurately. That’s not a lot to ask, is it? But that’s not what Donna Brazile did when she discussed the procedures of the DNC’s Credential Committee on ABC’s This Week With George Stephanopoulos.
[UPDATE: I like what Paul Krugman says in the video about what he hears from "grassroots" Hillary supporters. I am grateful that SOMEONE is listening to people like me and you. Of course, Donna Brazile butts in, and ignores Krugman's entire point as well as his plea. -- SusanUnPC]
Brazile said:
I think we have an exit strategy in the Democratic party to end the primary season on June 10th. That’s the end of the primary season based on the rules, and after all this is about the rules. So sometime before July 4th, I am clear that the super-delegates will break one way or another and this thing will end. Whoever is coming up with this new strategy is not looking at the map again.
Howard Dean has already appointed 25 members [of the credentials committee]. The states will send three persons, three people to the convention, on the Credentials Committee. Obama has won more states.
Enter those pesky rules (damn them when they aren’t going your way). The rules state:
Each standing committee shall be composed of: People allocated to the states and territories in accordance with the same distribution formula used to allocate delegates to the Democratic National Convention.
The rules of the DNC further state on pages 8 and 9:
A. Membership: Subject to Rule 20.C. of the Delegate Selection Rules, each standing committee shall be composed of:
1. Base: A base of 161 members, casting 158 votes, allocated to the states and territories in accordance with the same distribution formula used to allocate delegates to the Democratic National Convention.
2. PLEOs: 25 members, each casting one (1) vote who shall be Party Leaders and Elected Officials.
TalkLeft‘s Big Tent Democrat analyzed ongoing discussions on the credentials committee process at another blog, and discovered that they have it right. Explains BTD:
- Obama presently has 70.22 votes.
- Clinton has 61.44 votes.
- Up for grabs in the 10 States are 26.33 votes.
- Dean has already seated the 25 votes allowed by the DNC that are not included in the candidates’ totals!
This does not favor Clinton (what a surprise!), because Dean seats who he wants to seat, and knowing Dean and Donna Brazile, can you guess who those 25 DNC votes are pre-set to go to?
So, as you can see, Donna Brazile deliberately gave the public misleading information, and she should be called on it — which we are doing right now.
Transparency would be nice, Governor Dean, although that does seem like too much to ask of you these days! We would like to think we are at least still living in a partial Democracy, so stacking the deck is not appreciated!
Brazile’s misinformation doesn’t stop there though. She left out an important part. There’s the Florida and Michigan “problem,” also known in real democracies as disenfranchisement. Some quick math tells us that Florida and Michigan delegate counts would provide roughly an additional 16 to 18 votes on the Credentials Committee. However, this won’t happen, thanks to Senator Obama who decided against “allowing” the people of both states to re-vote.
In short, Senator Obama, with the collusive help of Howard Dean, has cleverly set himself up for his own win by disenfranchising those pesky Florida and Michigan voters. The Fix Is In.
And we thought we were living in a democracy!






















