Florida Caller to C-Span Nails the Crux of Obama’s Offensive Remarks about Small-Town Pennsylvanians
By SusanUnPC on April 13, 2008 at 11:44 AM in Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, Pennsylvania, Republicans
This is a must-watch video clip from C-Span’s Washington Journal, this morning — via Truthtelling007′s YouTube page:
Truer words. This articulate caller gets the media’s mis-focus on his remarks. She gets what Obama was saying: that small-minded small-town Pennsylvanians are bigots. She also gets that his comments will do longterm damage to his candidacy (particularly if he’s the nominee in the general election).
For more on the longterm damage, see the comments of Mayor Steve Reed of Harrisburg, Pennsylvania yesterday on a conference call … and don’t miss the new “Photoshopped” poster of Barack Obama that is cropping up on all the conservative and rightwing blogs:
Mayor Steve Reed, Harrisburg, PA, on yesterday’s conference call — and you can listen to the audio of the call that included a number of Pennsylvania mayors and National Campaign Co-chair and Fmr. Gov. Tom Vilsack):
Thanks very much, Mayor. Just for way of background, I’ve been the Mayor of Harrisburg now – I’m in my 27th year. Born and raised here in Pennsylvania. Born and raised in a small town as a matter of fact. The irony about Pennsylvania is that we really only have two large towns. Philadelphia and Pittsburgh. Just about every other place could be classified as a small town or a borough, or a township, or whatever.
We happen to like our small town values. We think they’re the bedrock of the American values that have built this nation and the people of our towns embrace their religions out of faith, not out of bitterness or frustration.
I have found our small town citizens to be decent. They are hardworking. They are friendly. They are giving. They are caring. They are patriotic.
Frankly, they don’t deserve to be categorized as they were in the remarks made out in California. It’s a very unfortunate stereotype of the citizens of our towns in this state, and in every state across the nation, to have them unfairly categorized as they were.
Frankly, the remarks of Senator Obama lacked judgment. They lack understanding. Frankly the remarks are condescending, they are negative, they are hurtful. I found it to be most revealing of what the candidate really thinks of us.
And it’s telling to me that these remarks were made several thousand miles away from us at a very expensive fundraising campaign event in a very upscale location when he did not think that any of us were ever going to hear what he had to say.
All of this in my mind invites the question of what else does this candidate think about all of the different people who make up our rather diverse nation.
[Susan's Note: Below, I have italicized the portions of Mayor Reed's comments that were aired and discussed yesterday on Fox News's election coverage.]
His remarks – I was listening to CNN last night with different commentators – Ed Rollins for example, and others and so forth – they are licking their chops.
This is perfect ammunition for them [the Republicans] to use in the fall campaign. They will eviscerate Senator Obama if he became the nominee with comments like this.
It will play all across America. Midwest, West, East, South. Frankly, I think they were ill advised remarks. They lacked judgment. And they’re condescending. And most of all, they are very divisive, which is in complete contrast to the rhetoric we hear from him at the public events when he knows the cameras are running.
I’m supporting Hillary Clinton. I do so without hesitation. Her roots are in Pennsylvania. She understands the people of this state. She understands small town values. She’d make a terrific president. She’ll bring us together.
Listen to the audio, and read the full transcript.
ALSO: Check out the responses by elected officials in West Virginia, Kentucky, Indiana, and Oregon, as well as the remarks of Hillary Clinton and her campaign.



















