RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

The Death of Baghdad

by
Larry C Johnson

Civil society depends ultimately on the ability of the government to protect the safety and security of its people.  If someone commits murder, we look to the government officials to find the culprit, arrest and try the suspect, and punish the guilty.  When people lose confidence in the government’s ability or willingness to protect them, they have little alternative but to turn to self-defense and neighborhood militias.

Today’s story in the Guardian chronicles the horror and savagery that pass for society in Iraq. 

For Iraqis who suffer the loss of a family member, a dreaded ritual
ensues. Everyone knows there is no point in reporting a missing person
to the police — no action will be taken. The first stop is always the
morgue. The lucky ones find a body straight away. For others, the
morning walk past the coffins has to be repeated. Their search can last
for days.

As a former trauma specialist in a hospital casualty
department, Dr Baker Siddique, 29, thought he was inured to scenes of
carnage. But nothing he had witnessed prepared him for a visit to a
pathologist friend working at the mortuary.

“I saw a street packed with people and coffins standing up
vertically,” he said. “There wasn’t enough room to lie them
horizontally.”

His voice faltered and his eyes filled with tears as he
recounted the agony of a woman in black who discovered the bodies of
her four sons that day.

“I have never heard screams of pain like that,” he said. The
woman collapsed on the floor, throwing dirt over her head — a gesture
of grief and helplessness that has become tragically commonplace in
Iraq.

As the doctor talked to his friend, a police pickup truck
pulled up with a dozen or more bodies piled in the back. “I could not
believe that the dead were brought in such a way,” Siddique said. “They
were one on top of the other like animal carcasses.”

When the police found that no porters were available to help,
they threw the bodies off the truck. It was then that Siddique noticed
the corpses of two boys aged about 12 lying in the pile on the ground.

“Each had a piece of knotted green cloth tied around his neck
and I could see they’d been strangled,” the doctor said. He also
noticed round holes that were slightly inflamed in several parts of
their body, a sign that they had been tortured with electric drills
before being killed. “Even their eyes had been drilled and only hollow
sockets remained,” he said.

America, under the leadership of George Bush and Donald Rumsfeld, have
helped create this nightmare.  Our failure to create a safe, secure
society is producing a bloodbath.  Imagine that armed men come into
your home tomorrow on Father’s Day.  They grab your father and your
brother.  They disappear for two days until you discover their savaged
bodies with their eyes gouged out at the local morgue.  You cannot file
a police report because you do not trust them (they are staffed with
your religious enemies).  No autopsy will be performed and no one will
ever be arrested.  And George Bush touts this as a society worth living
in.  I encourage George and Laura and their daughters to move there
immediately.  If things are so peachy guys, lead by example.

The Clueless Decider continues to insist we have turned a corner in Iraq.  But instead of a broad boulevard we are facing a deadend.  We are in the alley of death and the only way out is to turn and walk away.

  • http://spaces.msn.com/mpumpky/PersonalSpace.aspx?_c02_owner=1 PrchrLady

    Larry, thank you for all you have done and continue to do. The story from the Guardian is so sad, and I can only imagine how horrible it must be to live there esp. at this time. And not only have we as a nation started this conflict, but our presence there is only compounding the problem for everyone.

    I know that it tears at my heart each day, when I pray for my sons and daughters who are in harm’s way. They volunteered to serve this nation, to protect and defend it, even with thier very lives if need be. Like so many other posters here, or thier family members have. It grieves me so that they have been put in danger for no sane reason. It tears my heart apart knowing as I do, that many will never recover from the wounds inflicted on them by a group of people who have taken control of our country, by less than honest means, for less than honorable purposes.

    Earlier, before the CIC (sic) started this illegal and immoral conflict, I read a post that has stuck with me to this day. I searched for hours in my files and on the internet to find it. I will share it with everyone, and ask that we remember that we will be called to atone for the horror that has been done in the name of America. And we must insure that it begins from the top down, not just the ones that were following orders. Our soldiers and sailors, and the Iraqi people who have suffered so much, deserve no less.

    August 20, 2003 CONTRIBUTOR ARCHIVES

    You Just Don’t Bomb Other People’s Kids

    BUZZFLASH READER COMMENTARY
    by Mary Walworth

    What you do with other people’s kids…. Well, you feed them, of course. You figure out what’s in your fridge that resembles what they’re used to at home. You talk to them. You find out if they would like to make a picture with paints or magic markers (though you secretly hope they say magic markers which are so much easier to deal with). You make them feel safe and loved when they come up to you looking a little scared wondering why mom hasn’t picked them up yet, and you say she’s almost here, she just called as she was leaving work — you’re hoping that accident on the Parkway isn’t going to add another hour to this kid’s wait — and wouldn’t you like to pick out a video…Magic School Bus? Dora the Explorer? You find out if they want white milk or chocolate milk, chicken nuggets or meatballs, a Power Puff Girls cup or a Barbie cup.

    These are what you do for other people’s kids.

    One of the things you don’t do to other people’s kids is bomb them and burn them alive. And blow the limbs off their little sisters and blind their little brothers. And send their mothers (stained with blood and stuck all over with little pieces of broken glass) running away from flames, shrieking with grief.

    You just really don’t do that.

    And you don’t kill their daddies. And you don’t steal their countries and their assets. And as for how you act when a kid comes up to you and says he’s thirsty, well, you find out if he likes ice cubes or just plain water, sippy cup or big boy cup or the Spiderman sports bottle or would you rather have the last inch of apple juice from the bottle in the fridge. You don’t cut off their drinking water and make them desperate with thirst and sick with cholera.

    And let me tell you, you just do not turn off their electricity! You’re supposed to turn on the night-light so they aren’t scared. Why on earth would you cut off their electricity?!

    And you certainly don’t leave radioactive containers lying around for them to drink out of. Or unexploded bombs for them to play with. No, you just don’t find that in the baby-proofing manuals.

    You don’t make their moms afraid to go out for fear of being robbed and raped. You don’t break down their door in the middle of the night and hold machine guns to their older brothers’ faces. These are just things you don’t do to other people’s kids.

    And your neighbor’s grown kids? You ask them if they could please feed your cat and water the lawn while you’re away. You need the money, we’ll pay you $50 for the week, that sound fair? You ask them what colleges they’re thinking of applying to. You nod approvingly when they say pre-med or something to do with computers. You don’t sit by and accept the fact that their leader is sending your neighbors’ kids off to have the most unimaginably scary, sickening experience of their lives for no just cause but simply to allow some rich people in certain corporations to get even more obscenely rich. You don’t sit in front of the TV and allow yourself to be brainwashed into thinking Saddam is connected to Osama and Iraq has weapons of mass destruction (when the facts do not support this). You don’t just figure, well, my neighbor’s kids are worth sacrificing so we can all feel “safe from terrorists” — freedom isn’t free! — they keep saying this on Fox News so it must be true! You don’t nudge these wonderful, almost-grown-up kids (you have that picture of them at their high school graduation, arms wrapped around each other — oh my gawd, check out those bangs)…you don’t nudge these sweet, almost-grown-up-but-not-quite kids who were rug rats not so long ago…you don’t nudge these guys into seeking self-worth by fighting in a war that will leave them permanently shattered and terrorized and scared…fragile and brittle from the horror…never fully able to stop hearing the screams of scared children and the moans of dying soldier-friends…stinging with grief and guilt and trauma for the rest of their days.

    These are things you don’t do to other people’s kids. Whether they live next door to you, down the street from you, across the country or across the globe. You just don’t do these things to other people’s kids.

    A BUZZFLASH READER COMMENTARY

  • Leslie

    Nice article PrchrLady.

    Many of the so-called “insurgents” are fighting against the US invasion and occupation, as anyone would if their country had been invaded. And the ill-prepared GIs in harm’s way didn’t ask for this.

    The Bush administration ought to tried for war crimes at the Hague for: the lies leading to a disproportionate act of aggression with the illegal invasion of Iraq, laying siege to areas populated by civilians, torture and prison abuse, indefinite detentions, corruption and mismanagement of the development fund and reconstruction, the use of banned weapons such as napalm and white phosphorus, the use of indiscriminate weapons such as depleted uranium and cluster bombs especially in population areas, and cutting off food and water supplies to civilians to encourage them to flee areas before military attacks.

    Full list of charges, see link: http://www.globalpolicy.org/security/issues/iraq/attack/lawindex.htm

  • kim

    Surely one sees the difference between the horror wreaked on a populace by a secret police and that by criminals.
    ===================

  • http://www.ignoranthussy.blogspot.com phinky

    Kim, what happens when the secret police are the criminals?

  • Semanticleo

    Surely a reasonable mind would recognize there is no difference between the two.

  • Leslie

    Raw Story is reporting this morning that Libby may be pardoned. What’s happening with Fitzgerald’s investigation? Is the investigation quietly going away?

  • kim

    SC, you sad sack of a sophist, may I remind you that there is little on earth so good as a good cop, and little so evil as a bad cop.
    =================

  • kim

    Pardoned from what?
    =============

  • Semanticleo

    Kim;

    Eat your weasel sandwich walkin’, bonehead.
    Retreat to the hedgehog hole you hide in when there is an issue that smokes out your patriot’s pantomime.
    Hire a nurse to bleed your bloodless brakelines and purge the air from your hollow mantra. Free that rotting carcass from the bloating gases that envelop your psyche and let us all breathe some fresh air for a change.

  • Leslie

    Semanticleo,
    I guess Kim has never heard of the old KGB and she missed the news that Libby had been indicted.

    Just ignore the trolls and continue the conversation as if they don’t exist. Maybe the powers that be will eventually ban them?

  • kim

    L, aren’t you getting the cart before the horse? Probably I’m mistaken, and one can be pardoned of an accusation, but unless the one accusing is correct, then the accuser needs the pardon.

    S, you are badly missing the point. Is it better that people die helplessly before the power of an autocratic regime, or in defense of their own lives in the public marketplace? Surely a rhetorician of your power can see the difference, but to support Saddam’s regime in Iraq over the present one requires the kind of intellectual dishonesty that gave sophistry a bad name.
    =====================

  • Semanticleo

    Kim;

    Now that’s a comment that deserves a response. No,
    that is a false choice. I hear no one supporting the former regime. What we have is a shift in power from Sunni to Shia, with an increase in chaos and comparable daily violence. Precious american lives and treasure have been expended
    with little accomplished except drawing the maggots to a carcass, and even that metaphor fails because maggots accomplish some good.

  • kim

    Actually, I think it’s a pretty good metaphor, good will come yet, and yes, there has been an increase in chaos. Surely, chaos is an improvement over ritualized horror. Please tell me you understand the difference, and that present day Iraq is preferable to Saddam’s. You should celebrate our role as catalyst.
    ========

  • http://spaces.msn.com/mpumpky/PersonalSpace.aspx?_c02_owner=1 PrchrLady

    “present day Iraq is preferable to Saddam’s.”

    Have YOU been there? have you read anything that those that do live there say? what evidence do you have of this? I know you support your ‘leader’s’ rhetoric, that much is obvious to me.

    I KNOW that I am glad Saddam is not in power, but I would rather that we had tried to secure ‘freedom’ at home here for them thru diplomatic channels, if that was really a goal… Instead, we have started a process (and I seriously doubt that it will end up being democratic)that has brought hell to many, many more… Do you really see that as something good? Do you have any compassion within you for the lives of those that have been lost, or damaged forever? Are you or have you volunteered anything but your ‘patriotic words’ to help our returnign vets OR the people of the country we occupy? Are YOU a veteran? Are any of your children?

    I was taught to LOVE my enemies, and do good to those that hate me. Doesn’t ever seem to get me very far in this world, so I know what kind of a response to expect. But if taking abuse, in the form of comments from such as you, or the likes of any of the right wing zealots, helps bring to light the horrors of this administration , then I guess it is time for me to say Bring It On. I know I have much wiser and smarter people than I behind me, who will cover my back. DO YOU?

  • Tim

    To paraphrase a line from the movie Full Metal Jacket “I guess the poor dumb bastards would rather be alive than free”.

    Sadaam was a bastard but I cannot believe these people are living better since he has been overthrown.

    First we were told they are going into Iraq because they have WMDs and connections to 9/11. We all know now that was a trumped up lie.

    Now Little Lord Pissypants, Turd Blossom and his crew of neocons are telling us they are there to liberate the Iraqi people. We can all see how that is not working out when the media isn’t too busy getting killed to report.

    Of course when people with real military experience like Jack Murtha point out the failures, people that have NO military experience and actively worked to avoid it when it was their turn to serve smear them.

    We do have countries that have WMD capabilities and we all know the strongest link to 9/11 is Saudi Arabia.

    The countries that do have WMD capabilities are thumbing their noses at us and Saudi Arabia is our ally.

    And the wisdom of the Republican Party is that the two biggest threats to America are gays getting married and flag burning. No evidence of these threats has been credibly reported but they never have let facts get in the way before.

    Pssst! Don’t look there. Look over here.

  • http://spaces.msn.com/mpumpky/PersonalSpace.aspx?_c02_owner=1 PrchrLady

    oh yeah, forgot to mention… I am not too worried about anyone ‘pissing on Larry’s or my graves’ either. Can’t speak for Larry, but it won’t bother me a bit… Maybe because someone does, it will mean that some flowers will grow, especially during the coming climate change and drought… I know I won’t be there, at least any part of me that would care…

  • RJJ

    Kim, thou sphincter, chaos is ritualized horror democratized.

  • Chris Vosburg

    Kim writes: “Surely, chaos is an improvement over ritualized horror.”

    Wow. Kim, you’re not funny any more.

    This is a sick, sick thing to say. Nevertheless, thank you for making it crystal clear that the lives and welfare of Iraqis could not possibly be less important to you, and you’d gladly kill them all if it helped your “team” win an election or stay in power.

    Know this, sick puppy: Ritualized horror is being visited upon the Iraqis every single day by decree of the executive branch of your government, and you are complicit. You put them there. Your hands are covered with blood, and it isn’t ever, ever going to wash off.

  • http://www.ignoranthussy.blogspot.com phinky

    Kim writes: “Surely, chaos is an improvement over ritualized horror.”

    Kim, if chaos is so much better than ritualized horror, why don’t you move your chickenhawk ass to Baghdad? I have a friend who is over there right now who would love to trade places with you. But I doubt you have the intellectual capacity to be an intelligence analyst.

  • Leslie

    I’m sure, since Bush’s Mission Accomplished speech, that all the dead Iraqis are celebrating the chaos and the “catalyst” for their new democracy as we speak. In fact, the chaos is such an improvement over Saddam’s ritualized horrors that Bush had to fly in secret into the Green Zone lest grateful Iraqis kill him.

    In case anyone was wondering if White House press secretary Tony Snow had learned anything from saying 2,500 dead troops was just a number…Snow added insult to injury on Fox News by criticizing the media for spending too much time on two kidnapped US soldiers. Snow wants the media to get back to Bush’s talking points. What a human being!

    http://thinkprogress.org/2006/06/18/snow-focus-kidnapped/

  • GR3

    Sociopaths are evil. Unfortunately, they are also mesmerizing the media. They are fascinating to watch. Just be careful what you say! The longer this administration holds power in DC, the more the world is made safe for evil. I grew up when evil was the Nazis. America is full of good Americans who will turn away from the horror of occupied Iraq, and ignore the destruction of the middle class, the US military, and even their own human rights. The question is when does the destruction become so evident that change is seen as essential? Many will flee, and many will use the same methods as the monsters in control – just like what is happening in Iraq. I’d recommend a book by Martha Stout, PhD, ‘The Sociopath Next Door’ to help people understand what to do with these folks – avoid them!.

  • Leslie

    The US embassy in Baghdad has written a memo to the State Dept. describing the deteriorating situation for embassy employees in the Green Zone. It’s disturbing and a must read: http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/opinions/graphics/iraqdocs_061606.pdf

  • kim

    Well, you sillies, the chaos is real, but highly isolated, and getting less chaotic daily.

    Although, that was some big time chaos visited on the Beheader. His golden hour was 52 minutes, but I’m not satisfied he regained consciousness; otherwise he’d have destroyed the Open, Sesame in his pocket.
    ==================

  • kim

    Jeez, guys, the war is over, the Iraqis won and are divvying up the oil. The thugs are getting arrested, the alien invaders are leaving, including us. Trust in Sistani, and the good sense of the Iraqi people; they’ve had a generation or two to contemplate how they are to govern themselves.
    ===========================

  • kim

    You know, it may well be tough for awhile in places where there is a lot of mixing of Shia, Sunni, and Kurdish populations, particularly in Baghdad, and probably places where Saddam wreaked holocaust and resettled Sunni. But a democratically elected government of leaders is gaining civil control. I cannot believe any liberal can believe this is not an improvement over Saddam’s rule.

    Hey, he’s still alive. Go to Baghdad, those of you crying chickenhawk, and restore him to power. A great leader of ours, a former Attorney General, is leading the charge. Uncle Saddam needs you!
    ====================

  • Gypsy

    It is amazing that our leaders have unleashed this violence with their incompetence. I am sick to think of it. We mean well as a nation of that I am sure but these are the unintended consequences of war and a war where the initial decisions were so bad, has been made worse by ideological decisions instead of by listening to the Generals who study and plan for war. I don’t even care anymore that the decision to go to Iraq was based on cherry picked intelligence or that the rationale has changed over and over, what really makes me mad is that having made the decision to go we did not do it well. This will harm our reputation for many years to come. What a nightmare for the Iraqi people that surpasses anything we had on 9-11. This is a nightmare that is 3 and 1/2 years old. And sadly it has nothing to do with 9-11. This is a national shame.

    No need to waste your breath, PrchrLady cause Kim is an appeaser. She would have gone along in Germany and found a way to say it was better. Dead is dead wheather it is from Sadam or from a foreign liberator. And the horror of 3 years of violence and your property being destroyed along with your economy and your lives and living in fear of kidnapping and ied’s. Yea I am sure the Thank you notes are in the mail.

  • kim

    Every Purple Finger is a Thank You Blossom.
    ====================

  • Mr.Murder

    It’s illegal to wear shorts in most neighborhoods now, blue jeans(western symbol) get death threats.

    Kim, do us all a favor, sign up for the front lines or travel to Iraq on your own. Wear your blue jeans there.
    Go ahead, make my day.

  • http://www.ignoranthussy.blogspot.com phinky

    I think Kim just demonstrated to everyone that she lives in a fantasy world.
    Kim sweetie, since you have a hard time with reality, why don’t you go home to little green footballs or free republic so you can feel nice and safe?

  • Chris Vosburg

    Kim writes: “Hey, he’s still alive. Go to Baghdad, those of you crying chickenhawk, and restore him [Hussein] to power.”

    Why?

  • billmon

    “Surely, chaos is an improvement over ritualized horror.”

    It seems pointless to argue with Kim, since he/she is clearly quite insane. But this particular line still has a high irony to it, given the recent conservative tendency to argue that security against the remotest chance of dying in a terrorist attack is worth the sacrifice of any constitutional liberty, no matter how precious.

    What was it Sen. Cornhole . . . I mean, Sen. Cornyn said? “Rights don’t mean anything if you’re dead.” Something like that.

    Why is the same not true for Iraqis?

  • Thinker

    Well I can’t say too much about a certain individual in view of my silent contempt, but for me, little ol’ me – Gypsy is as close as it gets to reason, good conscience and common sense. If everyone in America uttered comments like that. The World would respect you as a great nation. But as it is…….:(

  • kim

    Kids, kids, kidz. Do you really think that totalitarian suppression of dissent is preferable to the streak of chaos, admittedly mean, present in Iraq today.

    Don’t you remember last year, when your ‘chaos’ was Iraqi Minutemen in action? Don’t you? Hey, they were patriots.
    =================

  • Mr.Murder

    1-800-Go Army

    Et tu, kim?

  • kim

    Uncle Saddam Needs You!
    ================

  • Gypsy

    So Kim what will be your excuse next year when nothing has really changed there except that we have lost 3000 or 4000 soldiers and many more wounded permanently. Don’t you get it yet? They do not intend to leave. They will not say that we are leaving. We are there permanently. They are building permanent bases and the largest Embassy in the world. To the Iraqi’s and other Arab’s this means we are an occupier not a liberator. We are talking about a permanent, for the forseeable future, detachment of 50,000 soldiers. That is why they are fighting us. We would be fighting anyone in this country who came to stay also. But then you would think we were Freedom Fighters as would I. And you know what I would be one of them.

    Sometimes it isn’t what you feel yourself to be but what the evidence shows. I believe we are good people who mean well. I believe we are better than the terrorist who killed our soldiers but what difference does it make if a terrorist cuts off your head or a “Security expert” beats you to death in Abu Ghraib. There is no moral equivalency. They are both bad. We have to live up to our ideals to win this war. How is that going?

  • Mr.Murder

    Uncle Saddam Needs You!
    ================

    Posted by: kim |

    That’s your projection, not mine there kim.
    Don’t confuse Saddam with an uncle and touchy-feely issues here please.

    Both of them were republican. Unlce gropenfurher and Saddam’s republican guard- two sides of the same coin.

    Stop blaming us for what happened and pull your head outta yer ass…

  • kim

    You wanna feel good, go see what Uncle Rick Santorum released about Iraq and WMD today.

    Hi Hi,
    Ho Ho.
    Don’t want Saddam,
    No mo.
    ==============

  • JOLLYROGER

    Let me be among those heard to wax nostalgic for the good ol Baathist days.

    The most liberated women in any country where islam is the majority religion

    implacable hatred for islamist nuts (alas, we have our own nuts, vide Ms Kim)

    kids in school, not cowering in their homes unable even to play in their front yards

    women walking the streets without fear of rape (other than Uday and Kusay–hey, how many could they rack up in a day on mere frolic, as opposed to policy directed, institutional rape…?)

    No prospect of unconventional weapons spreading into the general population (Saddam ain’t ’bout to share….)

    Israel slightly constrained in its pogrom program (which, actually, in the long run, would have been better for Israel than the outcome of their unrestrained blood lust run amok–don’t cry anti-semit, btw. I am the founder of “ashkenazim for divestiture”.)

    You loved him in ’82, show him some love today. Welcome back to the squared circle, Saddam
    “el guappo” Hussein, Huusseinnn…

  • Thinker

    My wider concern, Gypsy, is not the loss of a ‘meagre’ few 1000 troops, but this does not develop into a pile of irradiated rubble.