RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

If Only The U.S. Had Always Been More P.C.

Written with the input of the highly imaginative Reverend Amy.

These days, says that old crab* Charles Krauthammer, P.C.-ness is “endemic.” He is such a pessimist that he thinks we’re hopelessly overcome by the P.C. crowd. Well, I must say, I concur. We are all so much more sensitive these days, aren’t we? If Americans had been as sympathetic to others’ travails over a hundred years ago, perhaps history would have been so much more progressive in its treatment of terrorists (forgive me, criminals), and the “report” of the tragedy referenced below may have been reported thus:

When John Wilkes Booth opened fire on President Abraham Lincoln in Ford’s Theatre in April 1865, the media was puzzled. “True, the actor was outspoken in his Confederate sympathies and viewed himself as a Southerner,” said someone who knew him, “but that was no reason he might want Lincoln to be dead.” The day before he went on his shooting spree, Booth hoisted a big Confederate flag outside his hotel room. After he leaped onto the stage he shouted, “Thus ever to tyrants!” the motto of the rebel state of Virginia.

The New York Times reported that Booth was psychologically unstable and was frightened of the Civil War coming to an end and having to face a peacetime actors’ surplus. “His political views had nothing to do with the motives for this tragic act,” it said, quoting experts. …

Can’t you just see something like that happening now? I heard this on Bret’s Baier’s Special Report yesterday and fell off my chair. In case you could not tell, it’s from a satirical site, “RubinReports.com.” The way things are going, though, it is possible that, in order to be PC, many real tragedies will be written up just like this.

………………..

*Of note: It is not anti-P.C. to call Charles Krauthammer an “old crab” even though it refers negatively both to his age and to his tone of observations. That is because Dr. Krauthammer is a conservative. I’d never say that about any liberal, would I. Especially if I were a commentator on the Lamestream Mainstream Media. I’m too tingly these days with the influences of Chris Matthews’ virile passion and the top Newsweek analyst Evan Thomas’s deeply profound and infinitely more fashionable definition of Major Hassan as a “nutjob,” not a terrorist. D.C. insiders are so much more cool and cerebral than the common people.

………………..

Truth be told, I am very, very fond of Charles Krauthammer’s always insightful, wry remarks on Fox’s Special Report and look forward to his columns, several of which Rev. Amy has discussed in her posts. It appears I am not the only viewer who looks forward to Krauthammer’s remarks since, one day, Bret Baier said that viewers in droves were writing e-mails demanding to hear Krauthammer’s views on a particular topic.

  • http://N/A breeze
    • Bronwyn’s Harbor

      that is profoundly touching and goes with what he did during his presidency, quietly keeping in touch with the families of soldiers who’d died. I’m sure Obama never picks up the phone unless so ordered, and that it is perfunctory and brief.

    • Dbb

      It is hardly a surprise that Hillbuzz, the loony extremist PUMA blogger who was dropped from the NQ blogroll some time ago, has discovered he or she misses George W. Bush and Dick Cheney. Nobody but a rabid Obama hater who watched his Veteran’s Day speech at Arlington and the day before at Fort Hood could doubt for a moment he feels keenly the sacrifices of our military men and women every bit as much as Bush. Bush, remember, never went to Dover AFB and banned cameras showing the arriving flag-draped coffins.

  • NomNomNom

    “peace time actors’ surplus”
    LOL!

  • Unabashed Galt

    I don’t have a problem with folks being critical of the whole PC concept. What I do have a problem with is indiscriminately branding a contrary opinion PC in order to dismiss a valid argument. I also think its possible to be sensitive and non-PC and get a point across. For example being critical of extremists of a group, without dragging in the moderates of that group to make one’s point.

    • Bronwyn’s Harbor

      I tire of all the caveats that one has to mention when one is making a point. E.g., it seems impossible to call Maj. Hasan a terrorist without also having to state that most Muslims are good people. That is a known fact, but one has to do all this tiptoeing. Ugh.

      • Bronwyn’s Harbor

        Btw, Mika Three-Zzzs on Morning Joe is especially tiresome in this respect.

        Every single time that Michael Vicks’ horrifically cruel crimes against dogs were mentioned, she just had to note that he got a longer sentence than many who commit crimes against children. Well, no s–t. But so what. Make the penalties tougher for those offenses too, but don’t demean what was done to those helpless animals.

        And, today, because she’s a liberal elite, she had no problem with repeatedly calling the weekend House vote “exciting” and “historic,” never mind that most Americans were opposed. And that was while she was supposedly “reporting” the news of the vote.

        • Unabashed Galt

          I’m tired of both extremes telling me how to speak and think.

        • http://rabblerouserruminations.blogspot.com Rabble Rouser Revrend Amy

          I have a hard time believing Mika is right on that abt Nick, but either way, he was out after two years and is back playing and being paid a mighty nice salary. Poor guy.

          And how abt all of those dogs he had? How did THEY fare?

          Sorry to be OT, BH, but you did mention it! :-)

          Oh, and thanks for the H/T, too! Sweet!

          • Bronwyn’s Harbor

            You deserve it. You should be a professional editor. You are so gifted at it.

  • creeper

    When is a terrorist not a terrorist? Answer: When Barack Obama is in the White House.

    I do not believe we will ever hear a member of this administration call Hasan what he was…a terrorist. Obama’s Muslim sympathies aside, to do so would be to admit that a terrorist attack happened on US soil on Obama’s watch. He’d rather eat nails.

    Further, I don’t believe we will ever hear a high-ranking military officer use the term “terrorist”. They’re off the hook if they can frame it as “he’s simply crazy”. If they can’t, American citizens will see them as complicit by their inaction.

    No one has anything to gain by acknowledging that Hasan was a terrorist. And for this administration, that’s all that matters. The truth be damned.

    Thank you, Bronwyn’s Harbor, for speaking the truth.

  • Hank

    OT
    Anchor Lou Dobbs says he’s leaving CNN immediately.

    NEW YORK – CNN host Lou Dobbs shocked his viewers Wednesday when he announced that he would be leaving the network effective immediately. The longtime host of “Lou Dobbs Tonight” said on his show that it would be his last and that he was ready “to pursue new opportunities.”

    He said CNN had allowed him to be released from his contract, which was set for the end of 2011 and that he was considering a number of options.

    “I will let you know when I set my course,” he said.

    • Unabashed Galt

      Fox bound?

      I’ll watch him there. :)

      • Carlaforhillary

        I hope so!

      • James W

        FOX?

        Ha!

        Third Party, anyone?

        • lark

          Palin….Dobbs….?

          • mountainaires

            That was my first thought too. People have been encouraging him to run for a long time. Maybe he’s decided it’s time to give it a try. I’m more interested in the reason he decided to leave CNN so abruptly.

            Inquiring minds want to know, Lou.

  • Carlaforhillary

    Charles Krauthammer is excellent in his analysis, almost always.

  • Bronwyn’s Harbor

    OT AND I NEED YOUR FEEDBACK: I’m testing. It seems to take a bit long for comments to save and appear. I just took out one of the newsfeed widgets and am hoping the page loads faster. Let me know if you notice it running faster.

    • Bronwyn’s Harbor

      Also took out the right-margin Amazon search widget. Tell me if both removals help the page load faster. TY.

      • Unabashed Galt

        Mulch (sic) better! :)

  • Peggy Sue

    I caught the John Wilkes Booth parallel setup on Baier’s show. Thought it was very good and gets the point across strongly.

    I think PC is going to get a lot of Americans killed if we cannot find a decent balance between vigilence and tolerance. The idea that some of the press is reluctant to mention Hasan’s Muslim background is insane.

    The DC sniper was African American and a converted Muslim. Did we all run around and claim Muhammad’s action and that of Malvo was an indictment against the entire Black community? Or Muslims for that matter? It wasn’t relevant.

    What makes Hasan’s religious background relevant is because he openly spoke about it and made it an issue before he even gunned down his unarmed military brothers and sisters. In my mind, that makes him a coward and a traitor, and yes, a man who is hiding behind an extremist point of view.

    On the other hand, I read some very disturbing, really hateful posts this morning regarding the Muslim faith–nothing redeeming, a filthy religion–while branding anyone who might take a more reasoned viewpoint as a Jew hater.

    I’m not a PC fan. Never have been. But that doesn’t mean hate speech is acceptable. We’re not going to win anything if we start sounding like the extremists themselves.

    Finding that balance is hard. But find it we must.

  • Betty

    I have made a decision, when ever I see a muslim woman walking around in a tent I am going to tell her to go home, she doesn’t belong here.

    And if she is with a man I am going to ask him where his “get up” is and then tell him to go home too. Neither belong here, neither deserve to be here. This is the home of the free and the land of the brave and he is a coward and there is no difference between her and a dog on a leash.

    I looked up how long there have been muslims and they have been around more then 1300 years. And in all that time not a one of them has stood up for the rights of their wives and daughters.

    What would you do if a neighbor, one who attends the same church you do, threw acid in his daughter’s face, or murdered her by running her down with a truck, or beheaded his wife after spending years beating her? I know what the men in my family would do. They would stand right up in church and denounce him and his actions. Has one of those cowards ever done that? Ever once in the over 1300 years those people have gathered together to “pray”? Who is this Alla Akbar that he won’t even protect a precious child?

    Every time one of them walk around with their leased dog they are thumbing their nose at this great nation and all the soldiers we are honoring today. So I intend to say “Go home, you don’t deserve to be here, when ever I see one.

    • Unabashed Galt

      And in all that time not a one of them has stood up for the rights of their wives and daughters.

      I don’t find your extreme position to be consistent.

      How does telling the Muslim woman to “go home, she doesn’t belong here” further the cause of women’s rights? I would think you would tell her to move in with you and escape her captivity to Islam rather then send her back to a country where she has even less chance of ever tasting real freedom.

    • mountainaires

      “Go home, you don’t deserve to be here.”

      Fortunately, as a foreigner living in other countries for much of my life [military], I wasn’t subjected to such rude treatment. Do you think American families living overseas while serving business or their country should be subjected to the rude treatment you’re planning to mete out to others here in this country?

      Are you the “ugly American” we hear about?

      You know, in this country we have FREEDOM OF RELIGION under our Constitutional First Amendment. So, you are actually planning to violate the Constitutional ideals of freedom with your plan. I hope that makes you stop and think. If it doesn’t maybe you should consider that the new “hate-crimes” law could impact your life if you decide to go around harrassing people for their religious views.

      Sheesh. Bigotry against all Muslims just because of Hasan’s actions isn’t warranted.

  • http://www.sonicninjakitty.wordpress.com Sonic Ninja Kitty

    What some people call PC, others call being courteous. So what if it takes a little extra time to extend the courtesy of being thoughtful and specific in making one’s point? When I am on the receiving end, I hope for and appreciate the same type of civility.

    Standing by while others are beaten is not being PC, it’s being an accomplice to a crime. Thinking before speaking is being PC and maybe we should be thankful for the benefits it brings rather than focusing on the extra effort it takes.

    Speaking of Lincoln, I just read a fascinating book, Lincoln Unmasked by Thomas DiLorenzo. It’s extremely unPC to Lincoln. Funny how there is a never ending number of viewpoints on any given subject. Usually we simply believe the first one we’re exposed to. Sometimes we need to reevaluate.

  • Cathy in Ks.

    Thanks for the wonderful post! I guess being “p. c.” is not new for us. Perhaps our tolerance and concern about being “politically correct” is one of the more admirable aspects of our national character as well as a weakness. The fact that we can have civilized discussions about whether Hasan’s murderous acts were those of a “crazed gunman” who happened to use his beliefs about the Muslim religion for his inspiration or that Hasan was acting as a Muslim extremist committing an act of terror, I think says volumes about the free society that we live in. There are far too many countries across the globe, where only one point of view would be tolerated.

    BTW, thanks “breeze” for your link to Hillbuzz. I cried when I read the letter. I, too, have been very critical of Geo. W. and sometimes it took on a personal nature for which I’m now profoundly sorry. When I read that he and Laura visited the families and injured at Ft. Hood last week, I was surprised. But as the letter so eloquently points out, although we may disagree with Geo. W.’s policies, as a person, he is a caring and kind man and was the right leader for this country following the 9/11 attacks. I, also have been taking a second look at Cheney. I do think history will judge Bush and Cheney in a more kindly light than our present time has.

  • http://www.vitabits.fr/antioxidant myrtille    

    Hello
    This is a good post and its very interesting to read about John Wilkes Booth and President Abraham Lincoln.I had no idea about this.I also like Charles Krauthammer.

  • DaveB

    Ah, yes, bloggers of the world cast off your PC chains and unite! In that spirit let me point out that Krauthammer is a cripple, a term PC has cast into oblivion in polite discourse but which accurately describes CK’s condition from neck down since a 1972 diving accident. And if that gets him off the hook on chickenhawkery for his Vietnam War nonservice, is it unfair to ask how in his condition he obtains the first hand knowledge that make his hardcore neocon views any better for his supposed erudition than any guy who plops down on a barstool next to you?

    Take this 2004 CK rationale for the Iraq invasion: “There is not a single, remotely plausible, alternative strategy for attacking the monster behind 9/11. It’s not Osama bin Laden; it is the cauldron of political oppression, religious intolerance, and social ruin in the Arab-Islamic world–oppression transmuted and deflected by regimes with no legitimacy into virulent, murderous anti-Americanism.”

    Once again for the amnesiacs, Egypt and Saudi Arabia provided 17 of the 19 hijackers, the UAE one, and Lebanon, the only country we have had remotely troubled relations with, one. So why haven’t we invaded Egypt and Saudi or otherwise fomented the overthrow of their oppressive, intolerant regimes? I know you NQers think every Obama enemy is your friend but you ought to draw a line somewhere.

  • mountainaires

    Time Magazine has Hasan on the front cover this week, busting the PC group-think and calling him a Terrorist.

    And, this pretty much backs up their argument:

    Final Hour Lap Dances for Hasan

    Like the Sept. 11 hijackers who spent their some of their final moments in a Las Vegas strip club, Maj. Nidal Malik Hasan repeatedly visited a lap dancing club near the Fort Hood base in the days before he allegedly killed 13 soldiers. One day, Hasan spent six hours watching women pole dance. Said one woman who works at the club, called Starz, “He came in on his own about 7.30 p.m. and was here until 2 a.m. He wasn’t like our normal crowd which is young solders. He seemed older, more mature, a bit shy and reserved and a little out of place but not abnormal.”

    Read it at The Daily Telegraph