RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

TSA’s Illusion of Security

News broke this afternoon of an alleged attempt by a Nigerian to light “firecrackers” on board a Northwest Airlines flight from Amsterdam to Detroit.

NW ap_plane_explosive_091225_mnFederal officials and police are interviewing a Nigerian man, who allegedly tried to “explode” a powdery substance aboard a Northwest flight from Amsterdam to Detroit, injuring himself and two other passengers, law enforcement officials said.

The man said he was directed by al Qaeda to explode a small device in flight, over U.S. soil, ABC News has learned. Authorities have no corroboration of that information, and the credibility of the suspect’s statements are being questioned, officials said.

The government had no immediate plans after the incident to raise the threat level, a federal government source said.

Ed Morrissey over at Hot Air commented on the incident noting, “He may just be a nut who smuggled fireworks on the plane, but still, that leaves the question of how he managed to do that.”

Well Ed, here’s how:

Let’s start with the fact that there is no screening system or requirement in place at international airports that will detect explosives. If the preliminary reports that the Nigerian brought firecrackers on the plane that’s not surprising at all. Fireworks normally do not contain any metal and will pass undetected through any of the walk thru metal detectors used throughout the world. Here we are 8 years after the 9-11 attacks and we still employ security detection systems incapable of detecting explosives.

Then there is the laughable TSA restrictions on liquids you can bring on board a plane. Here’s the TSA policy:

Make Your Trip Better Using 3-1-1
3-1-1 for carry-ons = 3.4 ounce (100ml) bottle or less (by volume) ; 1 quart-sized, clear, plastic, zip-top bag; 1 bag per passenger placed in screening bin. One-quart bag per person limits the total liquid volume each traveler can bring. 3.4 ounce (100ml) container size is a security measure.

Consolidate bottles into one bag and X-ray separately to speed screening.

Be prepared. Each time TSA searches a carry-on it slows down the line. Practicing 3-1-1 will ensure a faster and easier checkpoint experience.

3-1-1 is for short trips. If in doubt, put your liquids in checked luggage.

Declare larger liquids. Medications, baby formula and food, and breast milk are allowed in reasonable quantities exceeding three ounces and are not required to be in the zip-top bag. Declare these items for inspection at the checkpoint.

Come early and be patient. Heavy travel volumes and the enhanced security process may mean longer lines at security checkpoints.

TSA working with our partners. TSA works with airlines and airports to anticipate peak traffic and be ready for the traveling public.

Truth is you can get at least one pound and two ounces worth of liquids into a quart bag. So try this scenario on for size. Two terrorists traveling together pack their clear plastic quart bags with six 3 ounce bottles. That is 18 ounces each. Let’s also assume they put a binary liquid explosive in the bottles, such as PLX. And they have a small amount of TATP to use as a booster charge.

Under this scenario two terrorists working together can bring more than 1 kilo worth of high explosives onto a plane undetected. There is no required system in place that will detect the explosives in their TSA approved “clear plastic quart bags.” So Ed, you should not be surprised with the firecrackers. We still do not have a security technology in place at all airports that can prevent such a threat.

Eight years ago Richard Reid, an Al Qaeda operative, boarded a plane in London wearing shoes packed with TATP. He’s lucky he did not blow himself up just walking to the plane because the explosive is so volatile. He tried to light his shoes but, because he had pissed on his laces, they were too damp to light. His fellow passengers beat the crap out of him and prevented a terrorist incident.

So here we are 8 years later and we still have done nothing to prevent the threat from an explosive. I fully acknowledge that it is a threat we rarely see. But that excuse will not fly if a terrorist group decides to run the risk of blowing airplanes out of the air. Let’s face it, we never learn.

On that cheery note, Merry Christmas and Happy New Year.

  • ellend

    Thanks, Larry. My New Year’s Resolution is to face reality.

  • Mandelay

    I hope the TSA can read … and read this post.  
    Oh Madame Secretary of the Man-Made Events, this one’s for you!
    Merry Christmas and Happy New Year to you, too, Larry.

  • Rabble Rouser Reverend Amy

    Holy smokes.  That is some scary stuff, Larry.

    How is it that more has not yet been done in 8 yrs??

  • Solara 9

    Vey scary indeed!

  • raging

    witness on Fox is reporting a passenger jumped accross 3 seats to to wrestle the perp.

    the flight attendant who took down Reid had some meat on her bones compared to the average. a good argument for raising max weight limit. I’d fly with the Amazon woman anytime. she nailed him even after he bit her.

  • Elizabeth

    So here we are 8 years later and we still have done nothing to prevent the threat from an explosive. I fully acknowledge that it is a threat we rarely see. But that excuse will not fly if a terrorist group decides to run the risk of blowing airplanes out of the air. Let’s face it, we never learn.

    __________________________________

    You have to consider the “olly olly, oxen free” clause whenever incidents get 5 years in the past.

    Even worse, now that it is reported he may have been directed by Al Qaeda and was apparently already on the government’s no-fly list of suspected terrorists, according to ABC News.

  • HARP

    So close to having another “man made disaster”…….right Obama. =-O

  • HARP

    According to the news account, the plane landed safely at 11:51 am Detroit time. This would be 6:51 am Honolulu time. However, according to Politico, the Commander in Chief was not notified until sometime between 9:00 and 9:30 Hawaii time.

    http://www.politico.com/politico44/perm/1209/briefed_by_phone_230a356a-550a-4cb4-99a6-2a352a596f6c.html

  • Olivia1998

    Harp…can’t even picture what the news MSM would be doing to Bush.  They never let him forget about reading the book on 911

  • Yttik

    I know this is silly, but why don’t they just ban lighters and matches? You can’t smoke on a plane anyway. Instead they’ve got us taking off our shoes and bagging our cosmetics. It’s really difficult to light a fuse without matches or a lighter. What do you do, rub two sticks together?

    I have to laugh, the last time I was at an airport I swear a woman had a half gallon of nail polish remover, a keg of hairspray, and ten lighters. I was worried she was simply going to self combust before we ever got on the plane. Security was not worried in the least, they wanted the cork screw attached to someone’s keys.

  • HARP

    Apparently he was on a “no fly list” and bought a “one way” ticket.

    No red flags there I guess. Keep talking nice to them O bummer!!

  • Welcome to the Obama era

    That is the second terrorist attack on the US since Obama has become president and there will be more to come with this idiot in the White House.  Thanks to the libs politcal correctness machine manufactured and maintained by guilty whites and racist blacks, they are terrified to even check out or identify the most likely candidates for terrorism.  Obama’s politcally correct Major had all of the signs of a nutcase but who had the backbone to take him out of harm’s way?  No one in the modern political correct world has the backbone,  however, no one seems to mind if they pick out a 90 year old WW II veteran and screen him at an airport. 

  • Docelder

    Some of the screening also serves to give the illusion of security. As if by having your shoes x-rayed everything will be alright. It isn’t so. But it does sell more tickets on the planes if everybody believes that. But, anything for corporate America, anything at all. Their wish is our command.

  • Elizabeth

    http://despardes.com/?p=11515

    Flight 253 UPDATE: Abdul Mudallad Nigerian tried to blow up Flight 253. Mudallad’s name popped up on Terror Watch List Database, said Rep Peter King of New York on CNN today. Rep King is a ranking GOP member of the House Homeland Security Committee. Rep King said the Nigerian suspect claimed to have links with Al Qaeda and other extremist organizations. The terror suspect also divulged that the explosive device was procured in Yemen with instructions on how to use it on board.
    A passenger Syed Jafri (Jafry) sitting at seat 16G on Flight 253 told CNN the suspect was sitting on 19A seat, and “he saw a glow, and noticed a smoke smell. Then a young man behind me jumped on him.”
    According to the Huffington Post, a passenger “tried to blow up the flight but the explosive device failed, two U.S. national security officials said.” The passenger ” tried to explode powder taped to his leg with a syringe full of chemicals” according to the NY Daily News.
    CNN’s War on Terror Expert Peter Bergen told CNN that Nigeria had one of the least airport security measures and the suspect may not actually be a Nigerian but some one who may have used Nigeria’s Lagos airport to bypass security measures and fly to Amsterdam on way to Detroit. Observers are calling it a grave security breach.

    BTW, I understand that there are now a few airport with explosive detection tools besides chemical wands. However, security at many international airports is very lax. It can make the Mexican border look hard to get through.

  • jwrjr

    Obama would only claim that he “inherited” the disaster from Bush.

  • TeakWoodKite

    So who’s pet goat is it this time?

  • TeakWoodKite

    The good news is the plane landed and all souls were safe.

    The bad news is, regardless of where this person started the flight, it is my understanding that passenger lists are furnished before any flight to the USA, in this case Amsterdam. As Peter King reported that this individual WAS on a no fly watch list. (or “in the system”, if you prefer), Yet he was not  deplaned in Amsterdam. So he had a “dry powder” on his leg and a needle full of accelerant.

    I hoped the guy in row twenty gets a congreesional medal for “jumping” the IGIT.

  • donjo

    Hey, not true.  We’re totally secure. They make everyone take off their shoes at the airport and stumble around in the midst of their luggage trying to get them back on. They also consficate unopened plastic bottles of lemonade bought this side of the secure checkpoints.  And then they nail your tiny Swiss army knife. What a joke.

  • Pingback: Soldier4hillary | Global Network of Domestic Terrorism, Extremism & Operations

  • Chicago Joe

    He should be back in Washington immediately to determine what happened. He has been on a doaen vacations since he was inaugurated, more than I have had in decades of existence.

  • About

    a month ago I walked through airport security without a problem but as I was putting my shoes back on a secruity person came up to me and asked me what was sticking out of my shirt pocket.  I told her it was a granola bar and showed it to her.  She then took the bar and made me wait until she ran it back through the x-ray machine.  Now I understand the level of security; stop all of the white people who have granola bars that stick out of their shirt pocket and make a big deal about it in front of everyone.  Meanwhile, a terrorist can carry explosives on the planes and these idiots who are afraid to be called “racists” will wave them by.  Better to have others lose their lives than have the ultimate insult of being called a racist.

  • Ferd Berfle

    A comment and a question:

    1) I would like to know what this “white powdery” substance was. I know of very few explosives that are “powdery” in form.
    2) Has anyone considered that this person might just be a looney-tune from Camp Wannabe trying to light talcum powder?

    I feel another dismantling of the Constitution a-comin’ because we certainly *can’t* use actionable intelligence to direct security measures and focus on rea threats. 

  • Nik Willmore

    Ti’s not devils make flying machines go, but dirty strippers. We seek clean ones by blowing up planes. We murder to get virgin sex in heaven. It sounds odd to YOU, but we take it very seriously, at the Islamic Nut Company.

  • truthtelling007

    None of what you just said was exclusive to the “obama era”. 90 grandpas have been getting frisked since 2001, under the Bush administrations. So how does that become the “Obama era”?

    “Second terrorist attack since Obama has become president”.
    Oh?
    What was the first? Are you going to mention Major Hassan as a “terrorist” attack?

    Further, you didn’t read LJ’s article I guess, no surprise since you probably don’t need further information to keep commenting.

    There was no “political correctness” that would have influenced this flight from OUTSIDE the country. How do you blame American “political correctness” on a flight where the search should have taken place in freaking Amsterdam.

    Hate Obama all you want, I don’t give a rats ass, but tell the goddamn truth about our shared history here, will ya? Not to much to ask is it?

    ” No one in the modern political correct world has the backbone”
    Bullshit. There are hundreds of career professionals that are no hindered by some bullshit PC behavior that you condemn everyone with as if you are the exhaulted most noble clear minded patriot out there. Horseshit.

    Major Hassan has been in the military a majority of the time under the Bush Administration. His comments and history started back then, so how is it the Obama “politically correct” machine that is the cause of this? Anyone?

    When you start to get over your “lib” hatred and think straight, you’ll find there are guilty parties in all these confused political circles that contribute to this problem and it isn’t exclusive to one administration or political ideology. Get over this political quackery called “right vs left”.

  • truthtelling007

    He was not on a “no fly list”.
    He was on a list of suspected connections to terrorism, but it has been clearly stated he was not on the “no fly list”.

  • truthtelling007

    LJ, thanks for your ongoing work here at NQ.
    Its a damn shame though after all these years of your contributions many still can’t quit jumping to the first bullshit faux journalism standards of screaming AlQaida at every attack. Thus if a suspect says, “I’m al Qaida” all the good meaning Americans start agreeing even if that hasn’t been established.

    The papers this morning abound with “Al Qaida linked” terrorist and only a few have told the truth about this link. Officials have doubts about this connection and doubts are the safest way to go if you ask me.

    Is this guy a terrorist? Yes, by mere definition of his action he is that.
    But is he Al Qaida? Did he really get his “device” from Yemen? If he did get it from Yemen, is that enough to say, “al Qaida” again?

    If he is connected to al Qaida then so be it, but frankly after 8 years of this crap, half the time these jerks don’t have much more than bullshit in their head and a need to be dropped down the lowest well.

    If we are to truly defeat groups like al Qaida, we can’t just call everyone al Qaida and fight blindly. Know Thy Enemy.

  • truthtelling007

    But you have improperly concluded that “white people” can’t be the next one who attacks. You have concluded by your comment that “white people” are clean and ready to go for screening and everyone else is a suspect. I’d check your comment again for some realization that…this is BS.

    Adam Ghadan, aka Azzam the American, is a “white boy” from California who wanted to go play Jihad. You really think that there aren’t “white people” who will go pick up Fatwas? You’re confused then.

    Now don’t get me wrong, there are some stupid security staffers who do stupid things as this search for “terrorists” takes place, but your almost arguing for a white exclusion policy here and all Politically Correct notions aside, it would be a strategic blunder to teach security, “white old grandma’s will not attack you”.

    When you teach security staff to omit a group for inspection, you just created a group by which you could exploit access.

    The techniques best required for the job have nothing to do with “white” and are rarely being seen in this airport screening process. As LJ pointed out, we haven’t even installed detection for explosives. That would be a good start before you start creating White Only lines so white folks don’t have be inconvenience while we hunt brown people.

    Don’t want to be called a Racist, then be thoughtful about what racism actually is and don’t engage in it.

    Security gaps can be exploited by racism as well.

  • Guest

    Extra screening is automatic for anyone presenting passports of certain countries to board a flight in the USA. Maybe Nigeria should be added to the list. But passenger details for all international flights are transmitted to USA authorities before or immediately after departure from a foreign airport-so why was his presence was not picked up and the flight returned to AMS ? Forget racism, profiling or jihadist affiliations. A great deal of the blame for this particular incident must be borne by authorities.

  • The security person

    was an arab, and yes, you seem like a racist.

  • I did not

    get the memo that says I take orders from you.  If I did I would shove it up your butt while you are on knees worshipping Obama.

  • Larry Johnson

    You still don’t get it.  Short of strip searching or doing a full pat down, there is no technology in place at airports that will detect an explosive on a person.  Moreover, two people working in concert can bring enough liquid explosive on a plane to bring it down.  The current X-Ray machines will not detect the liquids as explosives.

  • TeakWoodKite

    First, Happy Holidays,
    Second, he was on a list. That list , as Rep Peter King said, was a list that he came up on, ”with in thirty minutes”. That alone should have prevented him from flying inbound, IF, the passenger list was forwarded to TSA as agreed to by the EU and the US and was actually “checked”. As Peter King said, “we ducked a bullet.”

    It is unclear how a “device” made in Yemen could have been brought to Nigeria. The got dropped somewhere.

  • stodghie

    truthtelling(not), take your racist agenda and you know what you can do with it. we don’t want to hear your political correctness and how we dare not express our thouthts or you will be offended. be offended, i don’t give a darn. be very offended and now shut up.

  • TeakWoodKite

    LJ, You think since  the posting of the TSA training manual, we will see more dry runs, testing holes in the security schema? Why Detroit? Because of the the guy that was taken down by the FBI in Detroit?

    The incidents always create more questions than they answer.

  • Guest

    What don’t I get ? That passengers always selected for extra screening shouldn’t include a thorough check of US intelligence databases or watch lists? And that perhaps Nigeria should be added to the list ?

    If the individual’s photo ID is a passport issued by the Government of Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Libya, Syria, Sudan, Afghanistan, Lebanon, Somalia, Iraq, Yemen or Algeria, refer the individual for selectee screening unless the individual has been exempted from selectee screening by the FSD or aircraft operator.

  • Neo

    <p><a href=”http://www.mlive.com/news/detroit/index.ssf/2009/12/commenter_says_he_was_aboard_n.html”>The ticket taker said “you can’t board without a passport”. </a></p>

  • Guest

    LJ, if you’re interested in laughably non-foolproof devices not even able to penetrate opaque containers, I travel to Japan every 3-4 months and there have been laser-based liquid explosive detectors in its Narita International Airport in Tokyo for a few years now. I’d be surprised if US companies didn’t have the same deployment for this country.
     

  • sowsear

    Patted myself on my back too soon…how do I keep my avatar from disappearing each time?

  • Yttik

    I guess on the bright side, individuals are taking security into their own hands. Apparently a passenger tackled this guy right away and the suspect only suceeded in burning himself.

    I think one of the best ways to be safe is to have alert passengers, crew, and security. There is no technology that beats a human being paying attention. People in prisons kill each other and take hostages with all sorts of ordinary items they’ve turned into weapons. Unfortunately humans are kind of ingenious with figuring out ways to kill each other. There is nothing we can do to make people absolutely safe besides maybe forcing everybody to fly naked.

    The Gov dropped the ball, but isn’t that often the case? I think they have a responsibility to the American people, but when all that stands between you and disaster is the Gov, you better have a back up plan. Our Gov has trouble regulating cabbage, let alone airline passengers.

  • TeakWoodKite

    I noticed this too. It was staying put until this Am.

  • TeakWoodKite

    The explosive powder on his body was undetected – first when he boarded a KLM Flight 588 in Lagos, Nigeria and second, when he connected at Amsterdam to Northwest 253 destined to Detroit, US saying he was travelilng to attend a religious seminar. According to ABC, he was on a US intelligence watch list but not on the US government’s no-fly list.

    In the interest of getting my facts correct.

  • TeakWoodKite

     According to a preliminary analysis by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the device contained PETN, also known as pentaerythritol, a highly explosive substance.

    http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/27/us/27terror.html?_r=1&partner=MOREOVERNEWS&ei=5040

  • TeakWoodKite

    Abdulmutallab was granted a multiple-year, multiple-entry tourist visa at the U.S. Embassy in London in June 2008, a senior U.S. administration official familiar with the case told CNN on Saturday.

    http://www.cnn.com/2009/CRIME/12/26/airline.attack/index.html

    Criminal Complaint ; http://i2.cdn.turner.com/cnn/2009/images/12/26/northwest253.affidavit.pdf

  • Jazzman

    Truth is TSA did not listen back in 2001-2002 to the pros and its still not listening.. Its  its just arrogance and stupidity, which can be more deadly than terrorism…….

  • Jazzman

    Truth is TSA did not listen back in 2001-2002 to the pros and its still not listening.. Its  ijust arrogance and stupidity, which can be more deadly than the act of terrorism itself…….

  • Jazzman

    You mean TSA does not deploy the mag that has the capability….right?

  • Jazzman

    Let me susplain, while there is no machine outside a GC Mass Spectrometer
    or a OVA and/or HNU whch can detect the liquids, of course in the case of the Mass Spec it would take some 8 hours to come up with the parameters of the liquid and the OVA and/or a PID Analyizer like a HNU are just down and dirty analizers. However the electromagnetic signature of a detonator can be detected by a mag and even if its not 100% fool-proof it would be slightly better than nothing at all..At least the mag being set off would tell the TSA Agents…Hey There lookie at me…….

    The problem? Last i heard there was only one company that could do this… But then again TSa does not like sole contracts…………………..

  • Susan

    Larry-

    When I go to see my sister in East Hampton,MA, I fly into Hartford’s airport. It is a small
    airport that I believe have these sniffing booths that all passengers go through.  After you go through security, you are directed to a booth.The door closes behind you. I believe that some kind of agent is released trying to detect chemicals  or explosive agents that may be on you. After screening the automated voice tells you that you can exit. I understand that these are very expensive pieces of equipment, but are they not worth it, so that these incidents can be prevented.

    I have never posted here before, but I  enjoy reading all of your intelligent commentary.

  • Susan

    Larry

    Please read up stream, I did not notice the reply ability. 11:41 PM

  • Susan

    He also paid cash for his ticket and did not have a checked bag that went along with his name. I thought that those were already big red flags.

  • cici
  • Pingback: Proactive Helplessness | Lexington Universal Circuit

  • mike

    It’s real easy to whine on a blog and pine for some unrealistic solution. It ‘aint Star Trek- we don’t have these handy little devices that harmlessly tell us what compounds are where. just by pointing it. Even Superman couldn’t see trough lead. If you know of some affordable technology than can see inside a terroirist’s body and tell the difference between feces and an explosive compound without bombarding us with radiation, than do tell.

    You want to be 100% safe on an airplane, than we should all be incapacitated- drugged and/or restrianed so that no aciton is possible. Only then are we safe. Only absolute force can stop someone who is willing to die. . .How’s that mind reader device coming along, by the way?

    That’s the problem with freedom- in the hands of evil it is a weapon. Are you willing to give it up to be safe?