RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

The Women Of The CIA

Reprinted from The Daily Beast with the express permission of the author.

The female CIA officers killed in December were a testament to the progress made in a historically paternalistic agency. Former CIA officer Valerie Wilson on the cracks in the spy world’s ceiling.

The shocking massacre in Khost, Afghanistan, on December 30th left seven CIA officers dead by an al Qaeda suicide bomber at their base. Among the fallen: two women, one the chief of base and reportedly a mother of three. She was no cardboard airhead figure toting an AK-47, but rather a highly trained intelligence professional who was doing her job when she and her colleagues paid the ultimate sacrifice. It is time to recognize that women play a vital role in ensuring our national security and that they are very much on the frontlines, taking all the same risks but recognized and credited much less than their male counterparts.

As a former covert CIA operations officer, I have always been nonplussed by the portrayal of female CIA officers in the popular media. The girl (and it’s always a girl) is usually nothing more substantial than a one-dimensional cartoon character, always stunningly sexy without much in the way of intellect to balance a heavy reliance on sheer physicality. For decades, the message has been drummed into the public mind that female CIA officers must rely on their good looks and clever ways with a weapon to be successful. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been asked by seemingly reasonable people whether I had to sleep with sources to get the intelligence, and did I carry a gun and have I ever killed anyone? The answer to each of those questions: no.

The female pioneers at the CIA were tough as nails—they had to be. I met some of these women during my time at the CIA and they could intimidate me like nobody else.

The CIA was the epitome of the “old boys club” for years. The World War II precursor to the CIA, the Office of Strategic Services, was often jokingly, but quite accurately, referred to as “Oh, So Social.” CIA’s premier spy cadre was carefully recruited from the male, moneyed, white, establishment crowd that went to the Ivies. For the first four decades of the CIA’s existence, the very few females that got into operations were usually drawn from the secretarial or support staffs. These smart, persistent, and gutsy women tired of seeing the men have all the fun and back-doored themselves into case-officer jobs—meeting and recruiting assets, planning ops, and in some rare cases in the 1970s, managing operations overseas. These women were tough as nails—they had to be—and they poured everything into their careers, often at the expense of their personal lives. I met some of these women during my time at the CIA and they could intimidate me like nobody else. My female colleagues and I owe them a deep debt of gratitude for their groundbreaking careers.

In the mid-1980s, with the Reagan military buildup to counter the perceived Soviet threat, the agency benefited and grew significantly in size. Under Director Bill Casey, the CIA loosened its recruitment policies, involving schools other than the Ivies. Additionally, they began hiring women specifically to go into operations. Of course, attitudes take a long time to change and many a dinosaur who thought women should really just be at home and not running clandestine agents still roamed the halls at headquarters. At one point, someone made an observation to me that I think helps explain the very slow acceptance of women ops officers in the CIA. She noted that white men, used to being on the top of the heap, in power and giving orders, identified most closely with young, white men like themselves. They understood them and felt comfortable being their bosses (“He’s just like me when I was a rookie!”). As a consequence, it was the young men who got the plum assignments and opportunities for advancement that didn’t come nearly as often for the women, despite increasing gender equality in the operational career track. The CIA’s increasing corporate commitment to diversity in the 1990s applied not only to gender, but to race and ethnicity as well. In the agency—as in workplaces across America—it takes time for attitudes and actions to catch up to the broader aspirations espoused at the top.

In 1991, women in the CIA had enough of the blatant discrimination and protested to senior agency officials. In response, the CIA commissioned the “Glass Ceiling Study” to see if artificial barriers against advancement existed. Surprise! They did. Partly as a result of the study, the agency was forced to pay out $1 million in 1995 to more than 400 women in a class-action suit involving sex discrimination. The case cited lack of promotions, harassment on the job, and dead-end assignments. In my opinion, the lawsuit cost women CIA officers some ground because it tended to ossify ingrained attitudes that the girls can’t play like the boys. However, it was necessary and did eventually help level the playing field.

Despite these cultural obstacles, there is a long and storied history of women serving their country loyally. From Julia Child to Virginia Hall (an OSS heroine who worked behind enemy lines in France during World War II), there is no doubt that women played critical roles in maintaining America’s national security. From my admittedly biased point of view, I don’t know why it took so long for the CIA to figure out that in many respects, women can make better operations officers. First of all, women are less threatening and, in many parts of the world, simply blend into the background and are dismissed as of little consequence. This obviously works to a woman’s advantage if she is making a clandestine meeting. Women know how to flatter, are generally more observant, and definitely read body language better. One of the most important skills an ops officer must have is the ability to walk into an unknown and perhaps dangerous environment (and this can’t be taught) to “get it” right away. Finally, there is the simple fact that being female offers the immediately understandable and obvious reason to be in a clandestine meeting with a male.

As I was working my way up the ranks at the CIA, I began to look around for a female mentor—someone who could show me how it was done. Someone who was able to retain her femininity, able to juggle a family, and still be respected for her operational judgment. I’m sorry to say that I never found that role model. All the potential mentors in the ops arena, at least, were either divorced, had no children, or struck me as dysfunctional in some way. It was distressing, but not surprising. That was the legacy of waiting so long to bring women into the ops ranks in a meaningful way. The glass ceiling at the CIA, like most of corporate America, is still in place, but at least it has plenty of cracks.

It is obvious that one doesn’t join the CIA for public glory. You can’t tell anyone where you really work. If you are killed in the line of duty, no one knows your name. What you do get is a star on the wall in the lobby at headquarters. One doesn’t join the CIA for financial gain. If you are lucky, and work really hard, you might retire at a level of GS-15, and make around $100,000 a year. One joins the CIA because it is a unique opportunity to serve your country, and at the risk of sounding too corny, serving something larger than yourself. You are doing something interesting, often overseas. I believe that there is a clear link between how female CIA officers are portrayed in the media and the continuing, if diminishing, discrimination against women in the agency itself. The chief of base who died in Khost deserves to be remembered in history as a woman doing her job in a dangerous part of the world, not some silly cartoon character.

Valerie Wilson is a former CIA operative whose covert identity was revealed in a syndicated newspaper article in 2003. She is the author of
Fair Game: My Life as a Spy, My Betrayal by the White House.

.

  • Cindy

    Thankyou for this important and informative post.
    And, I must say, it is an honor to be commenting on your words.
    I have the greatest respect for you and your husband.

  • EllenD

    Intelligent, level-headed, clear thinking. This column demonstrates the loss to our country of not having this woman working at the CIA where she belongs.
    And makes me mad as hell all over again.

  • ces

    Thank you for your service.

  • Citizen70

    This article is a wonderful tribute to the Khost CIA chief and an informative description of women in the CIA.  Thank you for sharing this with the public and for debunking the way female spies are generally portrayed.  As a woman, I’m especially grateful because issues of sexual equality get so little exposure.

    Thank you to you and your husband for being true patriots and also for supporting Hillary Clinton.

  • Jazzman

    Yes I agree and bravo…However ,,,and there is always normally a …hiwever. The cover shop did a lousy job with the covers….. The Agency made another mistake and should have never acknowledged these were officers and as the Chief of Base, no matter female or male, made a rookie mistake and not only got herself killed but her charges as well and damaged the operations.. The fact that is was a women rather than a male is of no matter, even though women have come a lomg way in the Agemcy and like her charges she was a operations officer and that is no cartoon…. 

  • Jazzman

    Yes I agree and bravo…However, and there is always normally a …however. The cover shop did a lousy job with the covers….. The Agency made a mistake and should have never acknowledged these were officers and as the Chief of Base, no matter female or male, made a rookie mistake and not only got herself killed but her charges as well and damaged the operations.. The fact that is was a women rather than a male is of no matter, even though women have come a lomg way in the Agemcy. Granted like her charges she was a operations officer and that is no cartoon….

  • Jazzman

    Yes I agree and bravo…However, and there is always normally a …however. The cover shop did a lousy job with the covers….. The Agency made a mistake and should have never acknowledged these were officers and as the Chief of Base, no matter female or male, made a rookie mistake and not only got herself killed but her charges as well and damaged the operations.. The fact that she was a women rather than a male is of no matter, even though women have come a lomg way in the Agency. Granted like her charges she was a operations officer living a very dangerous life and that is no cartoon…. 

  • AnnieCarmel

    Excellent, thanks.

  • Eastan McNeal

    Valerie.  I do not know you.  I do know Larry Johnson.  His steadfast support of you and your husband tells me a lot.

    You say that  “one doesn’t join the CIA for public glory” but glory and shame can no longer be avoided as the CIA, once held comfortably secret, is no often exposed. 

    I thank you and your husband for your service.  I will believe news about you and your assoiciates when it comes from you, Larry or my friends in Congress.  I will treat any other information as assumptions.  I hope people who shape policy and shape the form of intellegence direction feel the same as I feel. 

    Fist person is the only true source.

    Again.. Thank You.

  • Eastan McNeal

    Valerie.  I do not know you.  I do know Larry Johnson.  His steadfast support of you and your husband tells me a lot.  
     
    You say that  “one doesn’t join the CIA for public glory” but glory and shame can no longer be avoided as the CIA, once held comfortably secret, is so often exposed.   
     
    I thank you and your husband for your service.  I will believe news about you and your assoiciates when it comes from you, Larry or my friends in Congress.  I will treat any other information as assumptions.  I hope people who shape policy and shape the form of intellegence direction feel the same as I feel.   
     
    Fist person is the only true source.  

  • Eastan McNeal

    Valerie.  I do not know you.  I do know Larry Johnson.  His steadfast support of you and your husband tells me a lot.    
       
    You say that  “one doesn’t join the CIA for public glory” but glory and shame can no longer be avoided as the CIA, once held comfortably secret, is so often exposed.     
       
    I thank you and your husband for your service.  I will believe news about you and your assoiciates when it comes from you, Larry or my friends in Congress.  I will treat any other information as assumptions.  I hope people who create policy and shape the form of intellegence direction feel the same as I feel.     
       
    Fist person is the only true source.

  • TeakWoodKite

    Mentors are rare. Thank you and all who serve in silence.

  • Rabble Rouser Rev. Amy

    Indeed, I concur (with others here as well).  I thank you for your service, and I am truly sorry at how your career was ended.  That was reprehensible.  I appreciate, however, hearing more abt the CIA, especially women in the CIA, from someone who has been there.  Thank you so much.  It’s an honor to have people of your caliber serving our country.

    And thanks to Ambassador Wilson for his service as well.

  • Linda Anselmi

    Valerie, it is a double blow that you are not still in the CIA – not only to continue to serve our country but to also provide that much needed mentorship to those women who will follow in your path.  Thank you for your service.  And for putting a few cracks of your own in the ceiling.  

  • AC

    test

  • SantaFeK

    A very good article.  Thank you indeed for your service.  I hope you will be contributing more articles/commentary.    

  • Ani

    Ms. Wilson, thank you for your moving article.  We know so little about the workings of the CIA and even less about the role of women in it.  We all had a snoot full of the glass celing in 2008 and saw the underbelly of misogyny many wanted to pretend no longer existed.  I appreciate your service to our country and your taking the time to point out the unique qualifications women bring to the CIA.  I’ts about time you all receive the recognition you deserve. 

  • oowawa

    I remember when Chris Matthews interviewed Valerie Plame Wilson on Hardball.  She was relaxed and smiled through the interview, but he seemed exceedingly up tight and intimidated by her presence.  His questioning and his facial expressions were unfriendly and harsh.  He spoke in a very rapid way, as if he were cross-examining a hostile witness.  Still, it is interesting to compare this Matthews with the kool-aid addled Tweety, his head in O-Land, that we see nowadays:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BCHZHFSYmy0

    There are lots of other videos featuring the articulate Valerie Plame Wilson on You Tube.

  • Linda C

    You should have read the comments at the Daily Beast…some  folks who really didn’t get it.  Thank you Ms Plame for your service to this country

  • Patrick Henry

    Its  nice to read an interesting article on this Subject from Valerie’s perspective.. and it  is fitting that it is posted here on NQ..where Valerie has so many fans and supporters..who are very pissed about Valerie getting “Burned” like she did..by the Bush/Cheney Operatives..

    That Incident just confirms her whole Point about male Arrogance toward Women on the Job..and even seeing women as “Expendable”when Convenient..

    I frequently associate with an Old Agency Warrior….who told me that all He ever tryed to recruit around the world were Females….and for all the Valid Reasons that Valorie spells out..

    He got “Burned’ too…by a U.S. Congressman back in the Frank Church days..

    I feel real bad for Our Team in Afghanistan..they did a good job..on Bad Turf..and Need to be Remembered and Appreciated..They all do..Its a dangerous and often unappreciated and unknown job..

    Like the team in Afghanistan..Agency people often get “Setup” and have no one Covering thier Backs..and should never assume they do..

    They do the job for all the “Valid” reasons that Valorie gives..just like your nieghborhood COP..They it to “Protect and Serve”..

  • PizzaDriver

    oh jeez, i was with her up until she mentioned the importance of “maintaining one’s femininity.”  women don’t need anyone telling them how to do their hair or what clothes to wear any more than they need someone thelling them what jobs they can or can’t do. 

  • anonymous renegade goes rogue

    This is without a doubt a outstanding article. Even more so since it was written by Mrs Wilson. You are officially up there on my list with our SoS for “women who run sh&t”. We hear very little about women and there role in national security. I had the opportunity to read about OSS and it was without a doubt fascinating to read about the beginnings of the CIA. When people hear “CIA” the first thing they think of is the description by the lamestream media. To include the loser brigade.

    My only problem is that I dont understand for the life of me why you guys get such bad press. I am sure Mr Panetta is personally a swell guy, however he may need to get a little bit more forceful in defending his people. Or get his balls back from the ACLU types and man up.

    You are correct about one thing. Women do have the ability to size up situations. Especially in hostile environments. That is something I know a whole lot about. One of the things that keeps me ahead of my enemies. Sometimes you have to think like they do and be able to walk into situations you know to be hostile.

    In other words walk softly but carry a big stick. (the stick is for smacking them down when the time is right)

  • anonymous renegade goes rogue

    Last but not least, thanx for supporting our SoS!

  • Diana L. C.

    Ibid

  • Helen in Seattle

    Thank you for this article.  It helps to hear this from you – one who knows and has been there.  And thank you for your service, and the dignity you have displayed in public statements and appearances.  My best to you and your husband.

  • EllenD

    Look, obviously women come in  different flavors of femininity (and sexual preference) but look  at what she wrote:

    Finally, there is the simple fact that being female offers the immediately understandable and obvious reason to be in a clandestine meeting with a male.

    She also wrote that in other parts of the  world, women are so  written off that men don’t even notice that you are there and speak freely in front  of you. As a professional you use the tools you have personally.

    If you are blonde and good-looking you shouldn’t have to pretend you aren’t to get ahead  in your organization, despite  all the stupid “blonde” jokes. It may be an advantge in your  clandestine job.

    Those of  you who have never been intelliigent blondes should know that blondes are dismissed more than brunettes in  a  work envronment and good looking women are attacked more than men in the same job. (Sarah Palin, anyone?)

    Good for Valerie Plame. Be who you are,  whoever that is.

  • Sassy

    Thank you Valerie, and all the other women who endure so much in order to serve this country!
    I was happy when you were finally allowed to speak out in the Congressional hearings. I watched every minute, and was proud to do so!

  • Retired

    Nice to read a well written, accurate article from a colleague.  The point about the “old girls” being tough and intimidating really brought back memories.
    My first PCS briefing was from one of those”old girls” who herself was the daughter of a well-known OSS officer.  She asked me what I knew of the country that I was about to be assigned to, wrinkled her nose at my answer, and advised me, “You don’t even know enough to be talking to me, yet.”  She handed me three books and told me to read them and come back and see her on Friday (this was Monday).
    A few months later, she was awarded the Intelligence Star for her service in that country.  And we remain good friends to this day. 

  • Ladydawnelle

    or to quote another Strong Woman – “BAM! taste my NightStick”

    thank you Valerie (and Joe) for your service and your honesty and your speaking TRUTH to POWER.

  • truthtelling007

    Great story. Thanks Retired!

  • truthtelling007

    There are few American service members I respect more than Valerie Plame. Thank you Valerie for your public voice on these issues. Many of us were supportive of you as your life was turned upside down by Cheney, Libby, Novak and others.

    In the days after Khost, I wrote to Larry as we were keeping up with his TV schedule and said this only shows how big the violation against you amounted to be. Real people are putting their lives on the line to help protect this nation, sans political winds, and yet just like you, this officer’s life could have been revealed by Cheney, Libby, et al, for the same petty reasons and just like you we’d have Vicki Toensing running around stating this officer was not covert or covered too.

    Its a shame I or others have to say, I wish I’d never known your name.
    Truth is, I learned so much more about my government, its history, and my role in this because of what happened with you and your husband, the honorable Ambassador.

    Hope to read more of your wisdom on this topic in the future.

  • Obama Pussy

    The women of the CIA, and US agents are the bane of any intelligence service.
    It is known by nearly every intelligence service on the globe, that any information provided to the CIA is received in Russia within the hour.
    The FSB has more assets in the CIA at Chesapeake etc, than the FSB has at The “Lubby”
    Dont ask me ask the Director of the CIA. Not an intelligence service, just the bane of all other intelligence services, as it cannot keep secrets!

  • http://www.wzfree.net/the-women-of-the-cia-no-quarter/ Best Art Blog » The Women Of The CIA : NO QUARTER

    [...] the rest here: The Women Of The CIA : NO QUARTER Categories: Books, Uncategorized Tags: author, betrayal, books, covert-identity, lawsuit, [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus