The Implosion of TalkLeft
By Charles Lemos on September 4, 2008 at 1:40 PM in Bloggers
Asset, Pronunciation (US): /ˈæsɛt/ (noun) 1. any item of economic value owned by an individual or corporation 2. a useful or valuable quality 3. advantage or resource
How bad are things at TalkLeft, Jeralyn Merritt’s once erudite and inclusive blog? In a word, bad. I have to wonder if Jeralyn knows what an asset she has, or better put, had in TalkLeft and that the value of that asset is not her just own posts until recently anyway and certainly not TChris’s posts which resemble Obama campaign talking points and offer little if any analysis but rather the commentary and insight of Armando LLorens who blogs as Big Tent Democrat or BTD for short plus the comments of a once large and diverse TL membership.
What made TalkLeft special was the diversity of opinion plus the civility and order of the conversation given Jeralyn’s well-thought out rules for discussion. Insults were non-existent, threads stay on topic and while BTD and Jeralyn set off the discussion, often the greatest value came from the comments. That’s certainly a big part of TalkLeft’s asset base — its membership.
The recent mental gymnastics of Jeralyn Merritt are indeed a wonder to behold. That she is a Democrat, I do not doubt and she has long been clear that she would support the Democratic ticket even though she was fairly ardent supporter of Senator Clinton. In this assertion, she has been nothing but consistent until Senator Joe Biden’s name started popping up as Senator Obama’s running mate. Jeralyn, a criminal defense attorney and a tireless advocate for reform of the criminal justice system, balked. After all, TalkLeft is a blog about the politics of crime that morphed into more, and she began a campaign against Senator Biden’s selection. She was none too thrilled when he was selected wondering if she could support the ticket.
Her indecision didn’t last long.
Within 24 hours came the first shot across the bow: “Time to Get On Board” in which she essentially stated that:
Voting is a personal matter. Regardless of how I end up voting or not voting, I encourage everyone, particularly Hillary Clinton supporters on this site, to get on board and focus on taking the White House back from eight years of abysmal Republican leadership.
But among the TL community many weren’t ready to “get on board” and many probably never will be and so there was some pushback. And that then led to Jeralyn’s decision to limit if not quell any criticism of the Democratic ticket. Valuable members of the community were no longer welcomed. Their opinion no longer valued. An asset destroyed. It’s her blog, she can destroy it if she wants to.
But the story doesn’t really end there. BTD’s convention coverage remained strong as ever, TChris’ weak as ever and Jeralyn descended into a page six columnist with posts on parties attended, drinks drunk and hors d’oeuvres munched posting pictures of Arianna Huffington of all people. If there’s one person that many in the TL community despise it’s Arianna Huffington. Many blame her for the vitriol that infected the progressive blogosphere with her hatred of all things Clinton.
Then came Sarah Palin’s selection and TalkLeft became simply bizarre. Governor Palin was compared to Thomas Eagleton who was forced to withdraw as McGovern’s running mate in 1972 over his pyschological shock therapy treatment. It was an unfortunate and unfair comparison. Harriet Myers might have been a better one. But the low point came when she decided to run a pool asking commenters to guess when Sarah Palin would be forced to drop out. From criminal attorney to Las Vegas bookie, the career path of Jeralyn Merritt.
That prompted the learned BTD to protest.
Speaking for Jeralyn only (4.97 / 34) (#62)
by Big Tent Democrat on Mon Sep 01, 2008 at 10:12:03 PM ESTI find this post utterly offensive.
Indeed, I disassociate myself from all of Jeralyn’s posting on Sarah
Palin.To which Jeralyn replies:
I know you disagree (5.00 / 2) (#109)
by Jeralyn on Mon Sep 01, 2008 at 10:24:52 PM ESTSometimes I disagree with you too. It’s good to have two perspectives.
Two and only two perspectives, I guess. It was offensive. That’s not a just a perspective, it is borne of moral principle. But for BTD the silliness and the draconian atomosphere may have become too much to handle:
A personal note –I am not comfortable with writing about this election right now. I am not comfortable with the behavior of some Democrats and Left blogs regarding Sarah Palin. Of course everyone is entitled to their own views on this and I respect that. But I am entitled to mine as well. I am going to take a break and see how I feel next week.
An asset is a hard thing to build and a terrible thing to waste, much less willfully destroy. I want my BTD, that’s the perspective worth reading on TalkLeft plus those of the commenters. Let’s hope BTD starts his own blog. I don’t always agree with BTD, but I always learn from him. BTD is the principal asset at TalkLeft. If he ventures out, they will flock.






















