Earmarks: Can You Hear Me Now?
By Pat Racimora on September 28, 2008 at 2:00 AM in Barack Obama, Earmarks, Joe Biden, John McCain, Sarah Palin
During the first debate, 16 billion dollars in this year’s earmarks were minimized by Obama as minor compared to the war and the bailout. True enough, but 17 billion dollars is still a whole lot of money.
But it’s not just about money! It’s the secrecy from us, the American people, and the potential for all sorts of abuse that should worry us as much or more. Although the idea is to snag funding for projects back home to keep one’s constituency happy and maintain incumbency, funds often go to reward cronies and lobbyists. Despite some recent legislation that attempts to introduce some degree of transparency into the process, the rest of us are still pretty much left out of things until the deeds are done.
And there’s more. Lawmakers can introduce earmarks after debate on a bill has ceased and often anonymously. So, when a vote is taken on a matter of significance, legislators are forced to also approve a slew of totally unrelated items if they also want the bill to pass. (Think flies on a piece of meat. I did that cartoon first, but it would have made you nauseous so I dumped it.)
And there’s still more. What can also potentially confuse the public is that your congressional representatives may have voted against a good bill you like, not because they didn’t also like it but because they disagreed with what it came tangled up in. To oppose an already inserted earmark, our reps must vote against the entire bill, possibly making them look like bad guys when, in fact, they may have only wanted to squash a boondoggle.
Not for lack of trying, the Obama camp could not come up with any disconfirmation of Senator McCain’s declaration that he has never entered an earmark for Arizona. In the meantime, Biden requested $342 million for tiny Delaware this year (his earmark requests since his election to the Senate in 1972 have not been coughed up, but it is assumed that amount would be staggering). Palin asked for an estimated 8 million as Mayor of Wasilla, Alaska (1996-2002) and, as Governor (since 2006) $254 last year and $197 million for next year.
To learn more about earmarks, see the new OMB data base that is a good start towards transparency, and a full explanation of earmarking by the Sunlight Foundation and Source Watch


















