Thursday Debate Rigged with Biased Moderator
By Matthew Weaver on October 1, 2008 at 6:37 PM in Barack Obama, Current Affairs, Joe Biden, Media Bias, Sarah Palin
Debate moderator Gwen Ifill has a conflict of interest and bias that is as obvious as it is arrogant. She is entrusted by the Commission on Presidential Debates to host a “a professional and nonpartisan” debate. But, in reality, Ifill goes to the debate with personal, professional, and financial motives to rig the debate against Governor Palin, whom she has already expressed bias against. Rig is not strong enough. Gwen Ifill will make money by throwing the debate to Senator Biden.
Gwen Ifill has written a pro-Obama book, The Breakthrough: Politics and Race in the Age of Obama. Not only is this book billed as “shedding new light on the impact of Barack Obama’s stunning presidential campaign,” it is scheduled to be released on January 20, 2009, Inauguration Day!
Ifill is a master drinker of Obama Cult Kool-Aid:
- Questioned recently about her biases, Ifill is quoted by the Washington Post saying, “no one’s ever assumed a white reporter can’t cover a white candidate.” But what about a “reporter” who has a personal, professional, and financial stake?!
- Ifill disingenuously observed when asked about the debate, that “I’m not running for anything.” Yet, she is selling a book!
- “Despite the protestations of her colleagues that she will be fair, Ifill has appeared on numerous radio and TV talk shows over the past several months to cash in on her access to the Obama campaign. She recently penned a fawning cover story on the Obamas for Essence magazine that earned much buzz. The title? “The Obamas: Portrait of an American Family.”—Michelle Malkin
- Anne Belle, spokeperson for Ifill’s PBS program, “The NewsHour” said “The book has been a known factor for months, so I’m not sure what the big deal is.”
- Gwen Ifill herself wrote August that “The Obama generation is just beginning its run.”—Time on August 21, 2008
Early this morning, Greta Van Susteren reported at Fox News that “the McCain campaign did NOT know about Gwen Ifill’s book.”
Later in the day, Senator McCain observed in a FOX News interview that Ifill’s book was “not helpful,” but he took the high road and said that he trusted that Ifill would be professional. Not unsurprisingly, some in the MSM and pro-Obama blogs, such as Greg Sargent at TPM, omit noting that McCain said her pro-Obama book was unhelpful and ill-timed. Michael Calderone at Politico and Carl Cameron at FOX News have offered more challenging questions about the matter. (See Politico for coverage on both.) Governor Palin, for her part, said that she was “not gonna let it be a concern.”
In the understatement of the day, Juan Williams of NPR and FOX News said:
“Clearly her books aren’t going to do as well unless Obama wins, so it looks like she has some investment, literally, in one candidate or the other. And she’s supposed to be sitting there as a neutral arbiter during the debate,” said NPR’s Juan Williams, a FOX News contributor. “I think the world of Gwen Ifill but I know there’s a perception problem.”–FOX News.
This is a mockery of the necessary impartiality of debate hosts.
Earlier today, I asked if the debate commission and both parties know about Ifill’s pro-Obama book and if she disclosed it to them. NPR’s Mara Liasson, who spoke with Fox News’s Brit Hume this evening, noted that Gwen Ifill has stated that she did not tell the Commission on Presidential Debates about her book. The Commission has not made any comment on the matter.
In marketing the book timed to release on Inauguration Day, Gwen Ifill and her publisher have published the following on YouTube:
Why would anyone think Gwen Ifill can be unbiased in questioning the two VP candidates as she has a clear personal, professional, and financial stake in seeing that Biden does well and that Obama wins in November?
Further, Gwen Ifill has a clear disdain for Governor Palin. Note her report at the Republican Convention:
To be fair, the book was not a complete secret. In fact, it was noted on September 3rd in a Washington Post as a footnote, “Ifill is working on a book called ‘Breakthrough: Politics and Race in the Age of Obama’. She focuses on the Democratic nominee. …” And even though Ifill apparently made no secret of her upcoming book, until today none of the recent major news articles on the debate disclosed Ifill’s clear conflict of interest.
As I wrote earlier, however late the date, Gwen Ifill’s unmistakable conflict of interest should disqualify her. It is to the discredit of the Commission for Presidential Debates that, despite her conflict of interest and rather clear support of Obama, Ifill was chosen to moderate the debate. It is also disappointing to see that the MSM is either ignoring the conflict of interest or not inquisitive enough to put two-and-two together when the information is right in front of them.
What can we do? Be a squeaky wheel and write or call the Commission on Presidential Elections and their sponsors:
- Commission on Presidential Debates at (202) 872-1020
- Janet H. Brown, Executive Director of the Debates Commission, at jb@debates.org
- Frank Fahrenkopf, Co-Chairman, no contact info
- Paul Kirk, Co-Chairman, no contact info
Sponsors (Thanks to Tamra Lahav)
- EDS, contact Christine Krumbholz, (972) 605-4658
- Anheuser-Busch, Inc., (800) 342-5283
- BHH New York, (212) 242-9242
- Howard G Buffett Foundation, contact Allen D. Greenberg, Director, Decatur, IL 62525-4508
- Sheldon S. Cohen, Esq., CPA, (202) 530-5600, (800) 390-3277, sscohen@farrmiller.com
- Director, International Bottled Water Association (IBWA), (703) 683-5213, Information Hotline: 1-800-WATER-11, ibwainfo@bottledwater.org
- The Kovler Fund, no contact info found
- Kaiser Family FoundationHeadquarters, (650) 854-9400
- Washington, D.C. Office/Public Affairs Center, (202) 347-5270
- YWCA USA, (202) 467-0801, advocacy@ywca.org, communications@ywca.org, or info@ywca.org
Please be respectful! For example,
Is it the commission’s position that Gwen Ifill can be non-partisan in the debate Thursday when she has a new pro-Obama book set to publish Inauguration Day? She has a clear personal, professional, and financial motive to make sure that Biden wins the debate and that Obama wins the election. It is discrediting to your organization that you have her slated to moderate. I recommend and ask that you replace Ms. Ifill with someone who does not have a clear, unmistakable conflict of interest.
Note: If you have updates to these contacts or others to share, please add them to the list or email matthew@theindependentview.com.

















