RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

Who and What is Cerberus….??

(bumped up)

While the debate in Washington over a potential rescue package of the domestic auto industry seems to be ending and a short term “bridge loan” is being arranged, I empathize with the innocent laborers and families within these companies and across the industry who have truly suffered from the imprudent management of this business model. One outfit that is heavily involved in this industry, though, deserves no sympathy. Everybody knows General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler, but not many people know of Cerberus Capital Management.

GM and Ford are publicly traded entities. Chrysler, however, is 80% owned by one of the largest private equity funds in the business. If any company understands risk, the cost of capital, business models, restructurings, leveraged buyouts, asset liquidations, return on equity, etc it is Cerberus Capital Management.

While the CEOs of GM and Ford most assuredly have extremely limited to zero means of raising capital at this juncture, to think that Cerberus does not have access to capital is ridiculous. The simple fact is Cerberus “chooses” not to put more money into Chrysler to defend their previous investment.

Over and above that as a private equity fund Cerberus is not required to publish financials. If it does not make your skin crawl to think that this crowd wants our collective money to support their investment, it should.

Let’s take a closer look at Cerberus:

Highlights include:

Chairman is former Secretary of Treasury John Snow.

Majority or significant minority stakes in companies that generate $100bln in revenue.
Philosophy: “encourage our companies to focus on the future through prudent capital investment, R&D, new product marketing, talent development, improved operations, and appropriate strategic acquisitions.

Earlier this fall, it was widely speculated that GM and Chrysler would merge to achieve significant cost savings through layoffs and balances of scale and so GM COULD GAIN ACCESS TO CHRYSLER’S CASH RESERVES.

Why does Chrysler’s CEO Bob Nardelli have his hand out looking for OUR money? Because Chrysler chooses not to defend its investment and inject more capital. In Congressional hearings last week, Chrysler Chief Executive Bob Nardelli was pressed as to why he does not seek help from Cerberus. He said he has, but was turned down.

Read more as to how “Congressman Opposes Chrysler’s Bid for Loans“.

Stop the madness, Nardelli and Chrysler should not even be offered a seat at the table. Congress should mandate that Cerberus OPEN THEIR BOOKS and in so doing if any money is provided to Chrysler it should strictly be done in the form of a totally secured loan against the best collateral (Cerberus’ top companies in their portfolio) and/or only after making sure that Cerberus’ entire equity stake in Chrysler is extinguished.

As this short term bridge loan moves closer to being approved, a “remaining hang-up was over ensuring that Cerberus, the private equity firm that owns Chrysler, would reimburse the government
if the auto company defaults on its loan, according to a Congressional negotiator.” Any banker on Wall St. or Main St. would absolutely require a loan of this nature made to a firm like Cerberus to be “secured”.

STOP THE MADNESS!!! Private equity funds do not deserve public money!!

If Cerberus does not want to defend Chrysler, then let another automotive company take them over through a liquidation process. Believe me, we’ll survive.

Give capitalism a chance!!

  • bart

    Holy cow! Agree completely! I had no idea Chrysler was mostly owned by Cerberus.

    Makes me want to go to business school so I can become a forensic analyst.

    • Strawberrybitch

      Uh Bart, all these boneheads that caused the problems in the first place went to some of the best business schools in the world…not a very good return on an investment, I’m guessing. And I’m sure you could do a better job without going back to school to study shopping…uh, I mean economics.

      • bart

        Can’t argue with that.

      • tek

        Strawberry: I think these people are getting a great return for their money invested in degrees: they’re raking in a fortune from the American taxpayer.

  • Galt

    Another crisis, another money grab?

  • eurogirl70

    Guess who sits on Cerebus’s board?

    None other than former Vice President Dan Quayle!

    • Mandelay

      Recent hires –off of “linkedin”– (see one from AIG)

      New Hires and Recent Promotions at Cerberus Capital Management
      What’s this?
      Rich Alexander, CIO within IT Practice
      was Chief Information Officer & Lean Six Sigma Leader at GE Commercial Finance – 5 months ago
      Kevin Rooney, Senior Compliance Officer & Assoc. General Counsel
      was Asst. General Counsel and Global Anti-Corruption Officer at AIG – 3 months ago
      Christina Zhu, Managing Director
      was Vice President of Business Development at Honeywell – 6 months ago
      Steven Faas, Operations Executive
      was Director at AlixPartners – 4 months ago
      Elie Azar, at Cerberus Operations & Advisory Co.
      was Manager at Ernst & Young – 3 months ago
      Behzad Taufiq, Analyst
      was Vice President at Cerberus Operations and Advisory Company, LLC – last month
      Benjamin Humphreys, Operations
      was Vice President – 4 months ago
      Kevin Gee, Fund Controller
      was Assistant Controller – 6 months ago
      Sarah Reich, Human Resources Associate
      was Human Resources Recruiter – 2 months ago
      Adam Hieber, CFA, Finance and Operations Professional
      was FP&A Analyst – 2 months ago

      • NavConsultants

        I worked with some of the Cerberus associates at GMAC when I was a consultant. I worked with Behzad Taufiq who was either a vice president or associate at the time. Unlike most of PE guys, Behzad wasn’t arrogant or cocky. He was smart, but humble pleasant to work with. Cerberus is similar to most PE shops in that there associates work both on PE deals and engage in portfolio company duties.

    • Mandelay

      Former Sec’y of Treasury John Snow is also part of the team. Plus –recent hires –off of “linkedin”– (see one from AIG)

      New Hires and Recent Promotions at Cerberus Capital Management
      What’s this?
      Rich Alexander, CIO within IT Practice
      was Chief Information Officer & Lean Six Sigma Leader at GE Commercial Finance – 5 months ago
      Kevin Rooney, Senior Compliance Officer & Assoc. General Counsel
      was Asst. General Counsel and Global Anti-Corruption Officer at AIG – 3 months ago
      Christina Zhu, Managing Director
      was Vice President of Business Development at Honeywell – 6 months ago
      Steven Faas, Operations Executive
      was Director at AlixPartners – 4 months ago

      PLUS — Former Sec’y of Treasury John Snow is also part of the Cerberus team.
      Elie Azar, at Cerberus Operations & Advisory Co.
      was Manager at Ernst & Young – 3 months ago
      Behzad Taufiq, Analyst
      was Vice President at Cerberus Operations and Advisory Company, LLC – last month
      Benjamin Humphreys, Operations
      was Vice President – 4 months ago
      Kevin Gee, Fund Controller
      was Assistant Controller – 6 months ago
      Sarah Reich, Human Resources Associate
      was Human Resources Recruiter – 2 months ago
      Adam Hieber, CFA, Finance and Operations Professional
      was FP&A Analyst – 2 months ago

  • wodiej

    I had no idea Chrysler ws owned by a private equity firm. As for workers, it is difficult for me to have much sympathy for autoworkers who cotinually sought benefits over and above what the average worker makes or else threatened to strike.

    • http://www.madinthemiddle.blogspot.com churl

      If I could join a union I would. Don’t knock the working man for getting a bit of the pie. Execs making millions, the people doing the work making thousands. Who deserves more?

      • jbjd

        Better yet, the people who determine what kinds of cars to make and who earn multi-million dollar salaries even on their way out of the firm do not have to forfeit those monies before getting a federal (read, taxpayer) bailout; but the line workers who have no say in the decision to produce cars no one wants to buy, are laid off; or lambasted in the MSM as money grubbing ne’er do wells, forcing bloated labor contracts on powerless management. It is these line workers from whom the public in general wants to extract their pound of flesh, in the guise of wage and benefits concessions.

    • AF catfish

      “As for workers, it is difficult for me to have much sympathy for autoworkers who cotinually sought benefits over and above what the average worker makes or else threatened to strike.”

      You mean the bank executives who continued to draw multimillion-dollar bonuses as the company tanked?

      I couldn’t agree more.

      • tek

        catfish: ditto.

        But, but, but…we can’t pay American workers a fair living wage and benefits because the third world doesn’t do that! Please, how about global standards for a global economy. Wonder if Americans learn anymore about the hundreds, maybe thousands of laborers, who died fighting for a fair living wage and a safe work place. The unions do have faults, but no unions is just stupid.

    • ParkSlope Voter

      wodiej

      Amen to THAT thought!!!

      -MS

  • Brodie

    This becomes “curiouser and curiouser” every day. Hell no they shouldn’t get taxpayer money. I drive a Chrysler product and I disagree w/this nonsense. If we can’t even see their books, that should tell us we don’t want to go there. And now we’ve moved on to bailing out investors, how about bailing out EVERYONE? ….no? I didn’t think so. They don’t seem to care a whit about all the folks simultaneously losing their jobs and their homes.

    • tek

      It’s Herbert Hoover all over again.

  • Blubber

    Why should Cerberus be treated any differently than the shareholders of GM and Ford? According to your logic than why are the shareholders of GM and Ford also not asked to put more money in? What is the difference if you have one shareholder or many shareholders? Cerberus has a hell of a lot of skin in the game already and without the Cerberus investment Chrysler may have gone done a hell of a long time ago. Not sure I understand your logic?

    • LD

      My point is that Cerberus has access to liquidity which the shareholders at GM and Ford do not. Cerberus chooses not to access that liquidity. Look at the statement that Nardelli made.

    • LD

      Also Blubber, any loan to Cerberus should be secured with collateral that they have.

  • Jason

    LD – minor edit “Because Chrysler chooses not to defend its investment ”

    Should be Cerberus, not Chrysler.

    Any government solution should completely eliminate Cerberus’ equity position, unless they are willing to put in more cash. That would be the result in a bankruptcy. I can’t see how any reasonable person would disagree with that.

    Frankly, any entity receiving bailouts should have their equity wiped out or at least be so diluted that its effectively wiped out (any new debt would have to come with massive amounts of warrants).

    • LD

      Thanks…you are correct. I agree.

  • oowawa

    It at first seemed very odd to me that someone should name a company “Cerberus,” after the 3-headed mythological dog who prevents the inhabitants of Hades from returning to the world of the living.

    Here’s Wikipedia:

    History

    Founded in 1992, Cerberus is named for the mythological three-headed dog that guarded the gates of Hades. While many of its peers have bought out companies in order to strip assets and sell on for a profit, Cerberus builds its reputation on identifying firms that are undervalued, and assisting in rejuvenating them by working with current management.[1] Feinberg has stated to his employees that while the Cerberus name seemed like a good idea at the time, he later regretted naming the company after the mythological dog.[1]

    The company has been a very active acquirer of businesses over the past several years and now has sizable investments in automotive, sportswear, paper products, military services, real estate, energy, retail, glassmaking, transportation, and building products. In 2006, its holdings amounted to $24 billion.

    On October 19, 2006, John W. Snow, President George W. Bush’s second United States Secretary of the Treasury, was named chairman of Cerberus.

    Although Cerberus owns 80% of now troubled Chrysler Corporation, it has refused to inject cash into Chrysler, as Sen. Bob Corker pointed out at a hearing about the economic needs of the American automobile industry on December 4, 2008. In response to questioning at a hearing before the House committee on December 5, 2008 by Rep. Ginny Brown-Waite, Chrysler President and CEO Robert Nardelli said that Cerberus’ other fiduciary obligations to its other investors and investments prohibited it from injecting capital.

    So Cerberus can’t help Chrysler, even though it owns 80% of it, because its money is busy elsewhere. But the American taxpayers CAN help Chrysler, because OUR money (which we do not have) is NOT busy elsehere.

    Maybe Cerberus, the 3-headed hound of hell, is the correct name after all.

  • sowsear

    Press conference Monday videos
    Bob Schultz from We the People http://video.google.com/videosearch?q=bob%20schultz%20press%20conference&rls=com.micro soft:*:IE-SearchBox&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&sourceid=ie7&rlz=1I7GWYF&um=1&am p;sa=N&tab=wv# This Video is 2 1/2 hours…

    Just the Rev. Manning portion

    http://www.atlah.org/broadcast/12-10-08_56kb.html

    Pass these around to the blog sites…

  • tek

    I see Obama has officially appointed Tom Daschle–a healthcare lobbyist–to “reform” the healthcare system. I also just read that Daschle’s state–ND–is ranked the most corrupt state in the Union.

    • Annie Oakley

      And to think that piker Blagojevich thought he was in that league…

  • Baba Rum Raisin

    RE: Cerberus

    Owning not one, but TWO MoPars, I followed the financial fandangoes relative to ownership of Chrysler.

    Diamler-Benz effectively paid Cerberus to take Chrysler off its hands. Chrysler is actually worth less as a carmaking company than its real estate is worth. Only the Jeep name and, possibly the minivan business are worth more than a bucket of warm spit.

    Cerberus is simply getting more Free Money, only from us this time instead of Daimler-Benz.

    Is this a great country, or what?

  • we’reallbondsmen

    Unions are fine but whan they start demanding $billions from other none-union workers who work at half of union workers pay–screw em.

  • fiscalliberal

    On Topic – I live north of Detroit neaqr Chrysler corporate headquarters. Not many people around here had any illusions that cerberus would grow the company. Damlier drained the company of tallent and wanted out of the US, and sold Chryler for a fairly cheap price.

    Companies like Cerbrus aquire and chop up for profit. Also the declining auto market along with Chrylser relative lower quality, pretty much put Chrylser at the bottom.

    Corker pretty much called it. They are waiting to get married and this bailout amounts to a facial to make things look better on their sheets. Just a different form of AIG and Citigroup et al, only smaller dollars.

    I would suspect it is the role of the Czar to sort that all out.

  • beaming

    The real issue here with this bailout, the one before it, and the trillions of dollars before that one is this. The people financing CEOs making millions, the corrupt politicians, the UAW unions making $ 75 an hour [ wage and benefits ], are the people making a national average $ 23.50 an hour [ scream at me if you want, I've heard a lot of numbers ]. It seems to me THAT is what isn’t right about all these bailouts.

    Can anybody say revolution, an underground cash economy, a bankrupt US government that can no longer borrow so it prints worthless money, causing inflation ?

    We need to as a country start making smarter choices.

  • justsomeone

    Wow! What an eye opener. Oowawa’s contribution really gave texture to the story. This ought to be on CNBC.

    • LD

      Just….in time CNBC will be directing material to NQ…thanks for the plug!!

  • justsomeone

    Sorry I don’t know how to e mail this story (whole thread) to Jim Crammer, host of Mad Money or I’d do it myself. His address is Madmoney@CNBC.com

  • Pingback: Who and What is Cerberus….?? : NO QUARTER

  • justsomeone

    as I write Larry Kudlow is kinda going at it with some guy from Cerberus

    • LD

      Just….perhaps Larry is also an avid reader of NQ…lol

  • http://ezinearticles.com/?Three-Basic-Parenting-Styles&id=744499 Northwest rain

    Thanks for connecting more dots —

    Perhaps the three US companies should go into bankruptcy and be combined into one company.

    I suspect that there will still be a market for SUVs — even if the gas prices go back up. Each company should concentrate on what they do best — and figure out how to make a decent RELIABLE vehicle.