The Limits of the Surge
By Larry Johnson on October 25, 2007 at 11:36 AM in Current Affairs
There is some undeniable good news out of Iraq–the number of U.S. combat fatalities has dropped by at least 50% of the average monthly rate for the last year. Still, U.S. troops are being killed and wounded on a daily basis. Some days are worse than others. Here is the latest as of Wednesday, 24 October:
10/24/07 MNF: One MNC-I Soldier attacked, five wounded
10/24/07 MNF: Coalition Forces attacked (Tikrit)
But the numbers are misleading and other signs continue to point in the wrong direction.
If the drop in U.S. combat deaths was a consequence of less fighting in Iraq in general then a celebration would be in order. But that is not the case. It appears that there has been a shift in U.S. tactics–fewer ground patrols and more air strikes (see Juan Cole’s commentary) . But it also appears that some of the Iraqi insurgent groups have opted to lay low rather than seek a head on confrontation. The real measure of whether the U.S. surge is working remains Iraqi politics; and on that front the news is not good.
Declining violence in Baghdad, for example, hides the darker news that we are witnessing the peace of the graveyard. The “improved security” is a by product of successful ethnic cleansing. The purge of Sunnis from mixed Sunni/Shia neighborhoods continues virtually unabated. Moqtada Al Sadr’s militia, working in tandem with Iraqi police, are expelling Sunnis from their homes. The following AP story tries to polish the turd but cannot hide the fact that the beat goes on:
10/25/07 AP: Baghdad Sunni teacher shot dead
Then there is the “other” political problem–the Shia remain in control of the key government ministries and are extending their control in that arena as well. We have seen no progress in reconciling the sectarian rift in Iraq. The only thing the Iraqi legislators are doing effectively is raiding the Iraqi police for their own personal security details. Imagine what the United States would look like if our Senators and Representatives could commandeer Federal and State police for their own personal body guards. Imagine that each member of Congress had a security detail of 50 to 60 guys.
Well, you don’t have to imagine that in Iraq. It is the reality. This will be Iraq’s version of a Blackwater scandal–security forces out of control serving the interests of legislative war lords. It is but one other sign that Iraq is devolving into a feudal rather than federal system.
And just when we thought we were turning a corner on the road to a new Iraqi democracy, we learn that the Kurds in the north are sponsoring terrorism. The Kongra Gel (formerly known as the PKK aka Kurdish Workers Party) is itself surging and attacking police and civilians in Turkey. Turkey, taking a page from the George Bush policy book of combating terrorism, has mobilized its Army and Air Force and has commenced cross border retaliatory strikes.
These events are adding to the internal tensions splitting what passes for an Iraqi Government. Most Shia and Sunnis Arabs agree with the Turks while conceding that Iraq lacks the means and forces to do anything meaningful against the PKK. They are willing to let the Turks clean out the PKK (and they hope that some of the regular Kurds get bombed in the process). Kurdish leaders, however, are not too eager to turn their backs on friends and relatives caught up in the PKK crusade to establish a Kurdish presence in souther Turkey.
So before you open that celebratory bottle of champagne to toast the success of the U.S. surge, some caution is in order. The political and military situation in Iraq remains a mess and there are no substantive signs that milestones are being reached and peace is at hand.

















