RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

The Manufacture of Consent

Salon’s Sidney Blumenthal quotes Walter Lippmann to point out, something which Lippmann observed almost 90 years ago, that “the crisis of journalism cannot be disentangled from the crisis of national government:”

“Everywhere today,” Lippmann wrote in Liberty and the News, “men are conscious that somehow they must deal with questions more intricate than any that church or school had prepared them to understand. Increasingly they know that they cannot understand them if the facts are not quickly and steadily available. Increasingly they are baffled because the facts are not available; and they are wondering whether government by consent can survive in a time when the manufacture of consent is an unregulated private enterprise.”

Lippmann had witnessed firsthand how the “manufacture of consent” had deranged democracy. But he did not hold those in government solely responsible. He also described how the press corps was carried away on the wave of patriotism and became self-censors, enforcers, and sheer propagandists. Their careerism, cynicism, and error made them destroyers of “liberty of opinion” and agents of intolerance, who subverted the American constitutional system of self-government. Even the great newspaper owners, he wrote, “believe that edification is more important than veracity. They believe it profoundly, violently, relentlessly. They preen themselves upon it. To patriotism, as they define it from day to day, all other considerations must yield. That is their pride. And yet what is this but one more among myriad examples of the doctrine that the end justifies the means? A more insidiously misleading rule of conduct was, I believe, never devised among men.”

Public opinion was not a free marketplace of ideas, but was channeled and polluted by the managers of news. They concentrated their power at the expense of accurately informing the public, whose fears and hatreds they exploited…

Read the rest here.

  • Mr.Murder

    Such has always been the case, only today’s technology has helped penetrate the fog of media control.

    Railroad king robber barons and yellow journalism once ruled the day’s muckraking.

    Exceptionalism long maintained its mythology until the new era arrived.

  • chris

    godbless Ed Hermann and Noam Chomsky for their revisit of Lippman’s work. “Manufacturing Consent” was a key to understanding media for me, and I’ve been a media activist/critic ever since.

    I would agree with Mr. M that blogging and video publishing, indymedia, and other movements online have challenged MSM to a point. But we are still lost as a whole at dealing with FauxNews.

    Again tonight, Hume took personal attacks on the Wilsons. I’m trying to find a place to post the clip, but he started by calling her a liar by parsing the “she denies sending her husband but later in the book discusses the email she sent to recommend him” and “their marriage was in trouble” and “she describes her husband as emotionally explosive and media craven” (paraphrases from memory)

    That slackjaw jackass has been one of the key figures in distorting the record and I have most of his distortions about this on tape. He uses his little panel to agree with his lies and he keeps quoting Kit Bond as his key source for Senate Testimony.

    Repeat a lie over and over until it becomes truth. Why do American’s do things that are against their own best interests? Examine their symbols and myths and you’ll see.

    Thanks leslie for the link

  • Fred C. Dobbs

    We visit Hearst Castle annually. Last visit, while considering where the US would have been without the Spanish-American War, which Hearst largely ginned up, I wondered what sort of architectural or cultural landmark Rupert Murdoch will leave us.

    Besides the Spanish-American War, there was little point to the hysteria surrounding the sinking of the Lusitania and our entry into World War I, another place the American body politic was dragged by the newspapers.

    This course is not new for our country. But it might be advantageous for us, as a nation, to attempt to, “Break the Cycle,” here.

  • mainsailset

    Many many many years ago my great aunt who was a judge & a doctor was asked to come back from retirement to sit on an ethics panel, the first of its kind.

    The first question posed to the panel was the definition of death….is it when the heart stops or is it when the brain dies?

    As a wee tyke sitting on her nearly 100 year old lap, I remember the crackling voice sternly telling me the story. It’s a strong question she said, one that reflects the soul and you must never be so arrogant that you assume you know the answer.

    It never ceases to amaze me when the media replace soul with arrogance.

  • ybnormal

    …wondering whether government by consent can survive in a time when the manufacture of consent is an unregulated private enterprise.

    The manufacture of consent can only matter if it’s ‘bought’ by someone. Traditionally, it’s been bought by many, because information has been provided by sources which, though not owned by monopolies, nevertheless have a monopolistic purpose, which is profit. In other words, the News Media leverage the sale of information to the buyers both by owning the source and by manipulating the content. This is the application of monopolistic supply and demand to information.

    So where does that place weblogs? They’re still evolving. But at least there’s an opportunity to shift some market control to the buyer, by making more choices available. The market variable of course, is how much buyers will choose truth over emotional gratification.

  • http://www.food4humanity.org HoosierHoops

    Hey All..
    Our son in Iraq, jordan, called us last night from a satellite phone on top of a building in Falluja.
    He is doing fine, loves the care packages, says it’s like Christmas every day..
    We are filled with joy today and wanted to share that with you folks..leslie, susan, larry, et.al.
    BTW.. I asked Jordan..So has it calmed down there with the surge and all? The media is saying it’s much better than it was..
    Answer: What the hell are they smoking? I’m in a war zone pops…

    I want us out NOW!!

  • mudkitty

    In the olden days it was called Yellow Journalism.

  • PrchrLady

    Hoops, I am so glad to hear your son is well, and holding on… I want them all home too, and my love and best wishes to all the men and women who carry the burden of so much on their shoulders. God Speed.

  • ybnormal

    See the Hearst Castle comment above by Fred C. Dobbs

  • ybnormal

    Suggestion FWIW IMHO: This Dodd Moment from today 10/26/07 along with video clip, deserves a posting. A true leader demonstrating true leadership.

    http://dodd.senate.gov/index.php?q=node/4106

    How did this guy get here? AND where can we get MORE?

  • http://cujo359.blogspot.com Cujo359

    The Hearst chain really showed us the way, didn’t they?

  • http://noquarterusa.net/blog/ Leslie

    Exactly Fred, that’s just the question I was hoping someone would ask: What do we do to “break the cycle,” as you say?

    Blogs are helping, new think tanks and groups such as the Center for American Progress and Media Matters help. Guess we just have to keep on pushing?

  • http://noquarterusa.net/blog/ Leslie

    Hoopster,
    Glad you heard from your son and he received all his care packages. Hope he leaves soon too! Hope they all do.

    You and PrchrLady,
    Please let us know if you need anything?

  • Shirin

    I’m glad your son is OK, and that he can feel like Christmas every day.

    What a shame his presence and that of his comrades is preventing anything like Christmas ever coming to Iraqis.

    I’m in a war zone pops…

    Right, and who created this war zone, and who continues to perpetuate it as a war zone?

    Hoops, may I ask you an awkward question? Does your son ever feel just a tiny bit of shame about what he and his colleagues have done to Falluja? If not, and if he is a decent person, give me 90 seconds to show him a few things, and I promise he will want to die with shame.

  • mudkitty

    And Hearst was supposedly an isolationist…he was Orwellian before Orwell…

  • mudkitty

    William Ince…

  • Bill Keyes

    Sorry to be off topic, but I just spoke with Susan, she sounds much because
    she is going home soon!!!

    ————-

    Bill, Sorry, Susan asked me to delete the day she’s coming home. She’s still recovering and it’s all a little bit much now.
    Leslie

  • chris

    thanks for being off on that topic. and for the update.

  • chris

    I can make a humble request of the blog maybe. I always have the basic insecurity that I don’t have my mind around the whole very well. That I’m running down so many details that I am immobile to act when called. It doesn’t drive me much, but it is ubiquitous none the less.

    While I think this keeps me endlessly curious and humble at least in the face of the cosmos itself, I think this is how I view most of the ‘key political movements’ I want to see succeed. I see that they too are so fractionalized that there isn’t going to be a tipping point any time soon.

    I call Congress frequently for info and my representative knows where I stand and I’d have to say listens a little, but is 1 in a body of 435 in one House.

    So, question is, what actions should accompany these great ideals I read on this blog? Its good to be informed, but thoughts about effective action is worthwhile. Or accounts of effective actions.
    Just a thought. Bless this blog. Good Blog Good Blog.

  • http://noquarterusa.net/blog/ Leslie

    Chris,
    I often feel the same way. Bet many do. That’s part of what’s nice about creating a blog community…and I’m referring to everyone who comments as helping to create that community.

    In terms of what we can do regarding this specific post…I don’t know. My hope when posting Blumenthal’s article was to start a discussion about what we could do?

  • Fred C. Dobbs

    Just say, “NO!” to mindless imperialism?

    Sing a chorus of, “I Ain’t Marchin’ Anymore?”

    Shucks, Leslie…if I had a good Answer to this dilemna, I’d put together an InfoMercial, buy some time on UHF stations in small markets and try to sell it for $39.95 + Shipping and Handling.

    The worst thing that happened to the USA in the 20th Century was buying the defunct Bristish and French empires after the end of WWII for a dollar down and a dollar week.

  • Mr.Murder

    Good words from a rooftop, how long before a chopper arrives to the Baghdad Hilton rooftop and whisks ours out of that quagmire?

  • Retired

    Blumanthal wrote in his article: By substituting propaganda for truth, brandishing jingoism to enforce conformity, and asserting arrogance and certainty over skepticism and humility, Lippmann contended, the manufacturers of consent confounded democracy. “In so far as those who purvey the news make of their own beliefs a higher law than truth, they are attacking the foundations of our constitutional system. There can be no higher law in journalism than to tell the truth and shame the devil.”

    Does this type of truth include honestly and unambiguously labeling a photograph in a blog so as not to deceive the readership into reaching an incorrect conclusion based on an assumed direct relationship with current events?

  • chris

    Good start by posting such topic, imo, because when we realize we are under a fog, we might think in terms of being in the fog. being blind in it and unknown of it is worse. I always considered myself a media cynic, but when someone like Ed Hermann and others can demonstrate “nameable patterns” that helped me a lot. The better I could describe the phenomena the more I could function in it.
    thanks to the good community here. the discussion is good sparring the driveby nitwits.

  • http://deleted lester

    the solution is this: bulldoze the fucking beltway. if the current left or right wing government isn’t spending our tax dollars on some left or right wing endevour, the pundits will have nothing to talk about and be forced to find honest work.

    there is no way to regulate the news. we need to stop washington from MAKING NEWS with our TAX DOLLARS.

    imagine a world with no pundits. what beautiful silence that would be.

  • http://noquarterusa.net/blog/ Leslie

    Retired,
    Assume you’re referring to my choice of photographs in my post below titled “Bush Visits California”? If so, I think there’s a difference between reporting and humor. My post was intended as a joke against Bush’s disaster response [not the disaster itself]. People were invited to make-up captions, to fictionalize events.

    But, you’re right, the original photograph should’ve been clearly marked as: Bush visits California and talks to firefighters in 2003. It was my mistake and I’m sorry for the confusion.

  • http://www.food4humanity.org hoosierhoops

    Leslie: Good evening..
    Please check the spam today..
    I sent a caption suggestion in yesterday..sorry..
    ( I was being a smart alect and submitted the caption in french..gawd it sucked..but obviously my french can’t pass the spam filter )
    :)
    ( English sub-titles were encluded)
    regards Leslie..

  • http://noquarterusa.net/blog/ Leslie

    Hoopster,
    I checked the spam filter yesterday after talking to Susan, sometime around 8 or 9pm. Didn’t see you there. Will check again.

    Meanwhile, try reposting while I’m watching for you, OK?

  • justsomeone

    I was looking at the news @msnbc before I came over here. I watched a little video about a U.S. soldier in Iraq, Tom Dearline, who got his advertising buddies, private sector stateside, to send clothes, vitamins & school supplies to poor Iraqi kids living in the slums of Sadr City. This soldier gets shot while he’s handing out gifts to the kids, gets his pelvis shattered..meanwhile his little foundation brings in 120k for the kids…Hey Shirin…tell me that ain’t Santa Claus. (Consider this equal time for our troops) Oh, Hoosier, your silence in the face of insult & dishonor makes me understand why your brave son felt he had to volunteer. Sorry man, I know you’re gettin’ beat up here..Please know I pray your son makes it home safe & sound. I spent some time with a friend tonight. Her son has 13 yrs in, he’s a Sgt, a tour of Afghanistan, 2 tours of Iraq & he’s being sent back again in January, he has a wife & 3 kids… sometimes I just can’t hack the good Iraqi/bad American song & dance.

  • timbshoe

      Everywhere you go now you find that the ugg boot has become the latest fashion new arrival cheap trend. now days it seems that you can not walk pass any window display of any shoe or fashion clothing store with seeing a pair of these trendy boots in them. it does not matter where ever you are in the world you will find ugg boots. these boots are both hot and trendy and certainly do not need to be worn in cold weather only. many people have found, that one pair of ugg boots is not enough.

      We have been seller of UGG Boots for many years.Our customers are satisfied with our products as we offer the real UGG Australia Boots:
           *100% authentic sheepskin for unrivalled comfort
           *soft genuine sheepskin heel padding
           *cushioning insole,flexible fabric-trimmed midsole.
           *Lightweight molded EVA traction outsole
           *Free shipping
           *One week to your door
           *If you dont like what youve received, simply return it! site:uggmax.com

  • timbshoe

      Sheepskin and ugg boots are a casual type of boot. Ugg boots are exceptionally warm and are great for cold weather (up to -30 degrees Fahrenheit)If you are looking for warmth while trudging around the house or the city, a sheepskin or ugg boot will be ideal.For girls and women, ugg boots look fantastic with tight-legged jeans tucked into them, or with short skirts paired with opaque tights or bare legs. For guys, ugg boots work great with jeans, and give a very casual, or rugged look, depending on the jeans or the shirt you wear with your ugg boots.site:uggsmax.com

      Do you have a pair of UGG Boots?If not,you must will buy a piar in our website.As we offer the best sevice and favourable price.what’s more,we charge the shipping fee.So,you just need to pay the fee of boots,and will receive our UGG boots in one week.It is very easy to have your own UGG Boots.Come on!

    Our UGG Boots are all with top quality:
          *features genuine twin-face sheepskin
          *our signature UGG woven label
          *feature a soft foam insole covered with genuine sheepskin
          *have a molded EVA light and flexible outsole designed for refreshing comfort with
    every step.site:ugghappy.com

  • timbshoe

     Australian ugg’s make great gifts for any woman including teenagers, college students, moms, and career women. they’re available in many styles and colors so you have a huge variety to choose from.Uggs are made of sheepskin with flat soles and a soft furry inside. typically, worn without socks, the ugg boots keeps your feet warm in the winter, but unexpectedly cool in the summer.
       
       Uggs have been around since the 1930s, when sheep shearers in australia wore them. these original boots were made of sheepskin all around, even on the sole. kids uggs sale today we have a hard rubber sole, making them more durable.site:timberlandonline.net

       Our website has womens ugg boots include styles such as the knightsbridge, the mayfaire, the ultra short, the ultra tall, the sundance, the nightfall, the classic tall, the bailey button, the metallic tall, the classic cardy, the classic short and the classic mini. the ugg classic cardy is one of the more unique styles in that it is made of a heathered merino wool blend that looks like a sweater on your feet.

       So many kinds of UGG Boots,dont you want to buy one!
    We offer many advantages of buy our products:
        *Free shipping
        *best service
        *fast delivery.one week to your door
        *If you dont like what youve received, simply return it! site:uggslike.com

  • timbshoe

     what’s the main point of the boots?the answer is to keep your feet warm.If you by one pair of boots put them on,especially in winter,you’ll feel very tenderness and comfortable.they can make your feet warm.and youll find its really fashionable.you can tie-in each kind of clothes with them and still looks beautifull.

      The ugg boots will definitely make you noticeable in a fashion-conscious crowd,and more importantly,is the fact that these boots are indeed quite comfortable to wear. these boots have been popular with swimmers and surfers since the 1970s and are regularly worn by surfers in california.the design of the boot with its sheepskin results in considerable thermostatic benefits.
      We sell real UGG Australia Boots in our website.You must be satisfied with our UGG Boots when you receive your order.The UGG Boots you get will have these advatages:
          *100% authentic sheepskin for unrivalled comfort
          *a durable molded rubber outsole.
          *The wrap around lace feature adds a fashionable touch with wooden beads at the end
          *A removable and replaceable sheepskin insole gives extra comfort and warmth.
          *Insole is made of sheepskin,latex. site:shoeuggs.com

  • timbshoe

    Legend has it that “ugg” is short for “ugly” – so, “ugg boots” apparently meant “ugly boots.” For decades, “ugg” was generic term used for sheepskin boots made in Australia.The word was so commonplace that it was found in Australian dictionaries, and ugg boots were also known as “ug” or “ugh” boots. But in the United States, when people refer to “UGG boots,” they’re usually talking about the boots made by Deckers Outdoor Corporation, the parent company of “UGG Australia.”So if you’re traveling the world and talking about footwear, it’s good to know that when the term “ugg boot” is used, it could be referring to an Australian-made sheepskin boot, or a popular brand name boot.
      We sell authentic UGG Boots in our website for many year.We offer the best service and favourable price.People all aound the world buy our products do not pay for the shipping,we charge it!

    Our UGG Boots have the advantages below:
          * 100% authentic sheepskin for unrivalled comfort
          * genuine twin-face sheepskin for refreshing comfort
          * have a molded EVA light and flexible outsole designed for amazing comfort with every step.
          *You can wear them up or style them folded down

      Welcome to buy UGG Boots in our website,we offer the UGG Australia boots are all
    with top quality!site:mbt4sale.com

  • timbshoe

     When heard of winter, cold may come in your mind at once.if you are ready for the coming of winter,you should never be afraid of it.it is not difficult for us that if you protect your feet well,you will fell warm and comfortable.so you should get several shoes help you spend the cold winter.UGG Boots can be done.for many individuals,ugg boots provide the perfect insulation and comfort for the winter months.ugg boots are both warm and comfortable.these two factors are extremely important,no matter what amount of time you are going to be spending out in the weather.ugg boots are made out of a material that is water resistant, meaning that no water,and no cold air,can get into your boots.they will keep in the warmth of your feet,because of their outer shell and their inner linings. once you slip your feet into a pair of these boots,they will be warm and toasty until it is time to take them off.you will be able to take advantage of the great warmth that ugg boots offer.e-uggs.com

    Welcome to buy UGG Boots in our website,we offer the UGG Australia boots are with top quality:
    *features genuine twin-face sheepskin for refreshing comfort
    *feature a soft foam insole covered with genuine sheepskin
    *have a molded EVA light and flexible outsole designed for amazing comfort with every step.
    *you can enjoy free shipping worldwide in our website.
    *1 week delivery to your door
    *sometimes you can get a special discount from our company by email
    Our customers are always satisfied with such kind of UGG Boots and our high service!-http://www.footwearmbt.com/

  • timbshoe

    The original ugg boots is not a brand name but an age old sheepskin boots generic term for this style of australian-made sheepskin boot. in Aussie slang, the ug name is short for “ugly.” in terms of comfort, however, the ug boot is a thing of beauty.Ugg boots are a popular brand of boot for women,and children.just as the chairman of australian ugg said, australian ugg is a good choice. once wearing it, you will be reluctant to take it off and be fascinated by its originality, reliability and extremely luxurious comfort. this is the art brought by boots. ugg boots make young beautiful girls and handsome boys very confident.addugg.com

    Our website have many fashion styels of UGG Boots for women and children.

    We provide many advantages as below:
    *free shipping
    *hidden costs
    *professional customers service
    *secure processing,plus
    *we dont hassle you on returns.if you dont like what youve received, simply return it!

    UGG Boots must be you best choice!-http://www.addugg.com/

  • timbshoe

     We have been exporter of UGG Australia Boots for many years,our product are all authentic.Welcome to buy any boots of them in our website,we charge the shipping fee.
    We just take 7 days to deliver the products to your door.
    As everyone knows,UGG Australia Boots in australia, and many other countries as well, ugg boots also ug or uggs are a style of footwear that has been used generically for well over a hundred years.Everywhere you go now you find that the ugg boot has become the latest fashion trend.

    Our UGG Australia Boots are all with top quality:

     *100% authentic sheepskin for unrivalled comfort
     *flexible molded EVA outsole
     *Insole features a genuine sheepskin sockliner that naturally wicks away moisture and keeps feet dry
     *Wool blend knit uppers with suede heel guards
     *Approximate Shaft Height (Uncuffed): 14.5″
     *By UGG Australia;Imported.-http://www.nikediy.com/

  • timbshoe

    Ugg Boots,also called Ug or Ugg boots,are nowadays one of the most popular boots.They existed already in 1930′s and became popular in 1960′s when Australian surfers found out,that they can warm their feet after coming out from cold water.They have everything you need-comfort and warmth.You will never be cold in those boots because 100% sheepskin will warm you even in the coldest days.The natural thermal properties of sheepskin make possible that Ugg Boots will warm you in the winter but in the summer your feet will not be wet.It is true that Ugg is shorter from ugly,but if you know even little bit about fashion you will know that Ugg boots are not ugly.We can see famous people like Pamela Anderson or Kate Hudson wearing Ugg Boots.
    Nowadays we have new improved Ugg boots for sale.You can get them for anybody.We have women boots,children boots,slippers and casuals.

    Our UGG Australia Boots are all authentic.Their properties and features as below:

    *In cold temperatures,the fleece works as an insulating layer of warmth and keeps the warmth of body heat inside of the boot.
    *In the heat,the wool fibers keep the air circulating; thus keeping your fee dry and pulling the perspiration away from your skin.Sheepskin also contains lanolin,which moisturizes your feet when worn barefoot.
    *ugg boots have reinforced toes,which are double stitched and extra durable heels.
    *feature a natural,thick fleece on a removable in-sole for arch support.
    *The sole is usually durable in most terrain,lightweight and provides traction as well.-http://www.timbshoe.com

blog comments powered by Disqus